THE CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT 2019: A HICCUP FOR E-COMMERCE ENTITIES

 By Rupal Jaiswal

[Rupal Jaiswal is a fifth year student of B.A. LL.B. (Hons.) at Symbiosis Law School, Pune.]

Introduction:

The Consumer Protection Act 2019 (“2019 Act”) notified on August 09, 2019 replaced the Consumer Protection Act 1986 (“1986 Act”) to further safeguard consumer interests in India. [i] This renovation was long-pending, especially since 1995, the year when online markets started mushrooming in India. [ii] The new class of consumers who engaged in e-commerce were not protected under the 1986 Act. In 2014, the Ministry of State for Consumer Affairs, Food and Public Distribution notified that the 1986 Act was equally applicable for protection of e-consumers. [iii] However, the problems faced by e-consumers were specific to e-commerce, such as delayed or no delivery, unprocessed refunds, delivery of defective or wrong products, unresponsive customer care services etc. which were not included within the conventional definitions of ‘defect in goods’ or ‘defective services’ under the 1986 Act. This necessitated the enactment of the 2019 Act.

Critical Analysis of the 2019 Act:

The 2019 Act is a landmark legislation on e-consumer rights as it aims to empower the Central government to frame rules to prevent unfair trade practices prevalent in e-commerce. [iv] In exercise of these powers, the Central government drafted the Consumer Protection (E-commerce) Rules 2019 (“the Draft Rules”) on which public comments have been sought. [v] However, the novel provisions for protection of e-consumers lead to a few grey areas and problematic implications for e-commerce entities: –

A.    Overarching and Ambiguous Definitions:

ii.         Product Liability‘Product liability’ refers to liability of a person involved in the manufacturing or supply chain of a product in case any injury is caused due to defects in their product. [viii] It was defined for the first time in India by the 2019 Act. It grants the consumers the legal right to claim damages for any harm, injury or death resulting from a defective products / deficient services, from manufacturers or sellers. [ix] Notably, the definition of ‘harm’ now includes ‘mental agony and emotional distress’ [x] which raises interpretational issues regarding the degree of distress or the proximity of harm caused due to the defective goods / deficient services before damages can be awarded. Product liability spells trouble for e-commerce giants which can no longer escape responsibility by tagging themselves as mere ‘intermediaries’. The ‘intermediaries’ defense (also called ‘safe harbour’ provision) was derived out of the Information Technology Act 2000 (“IT Act”) according to which intermediaries cannot be held liable for any third-party information made available or hosted by them. [xi] Remarkably, the Hon’ble Delhi High Court in the Christian Louboutin Case, interpreted ‘intermediaries’ under the IT Act to exclude those e-commerce entities which are actively involved inter alia, in selling and marketing of products, claim to have exclusive contracts with their distributors, or undertake guarantee of authenticity of products sold on their platform. [xii] The 2019 Act statutorily restricts the scope of ‘safe harbour’ under the IT Act by defining manufacturers to include even those which ‘assemble goods manufactured by others’, thus, making it possible for an e-consumer to hold e-commerce entities liable for compensation. [xiii] It is expected that these entities will become more alert and enter into indemnity arrangements with manufacturers / sellers before listing their products for sale. This will act as a cushion in case of liability claims by consumers.

Many provisions under the 2019 Act seem to overlap with pre-existing legislations. For instance: –

i.        Data Protection – The Act classifies disclosure of confidential personal information of consumers as ‘unfair trade practice’. [xviii] However, the same is also penalized under Section 43A of the IT Act. Since the IT Act also provides compensation for failure to protect data, there is a possibility that the provisions of the two Acts (2019 Act and IT Act) might clash with each other. Moreover, the pending Personal Data Protection Bill 2018 also harnesses the indiscretion of e-commerce businesses dealing with personal data of individuals, which makes the data protection provisions under the 2019 Act redundant. [xix] 

ii.          Sale of Drugs -The sale or distribution of spurious drugs is already an offence under the Drugs and Cosmetics Act 1940 and hence overlaps with the provisions of the 2019 Act.

iii.        Banking -With the inclusion of online banking services under the Act’s ambit, a consumer would be confused whether to approach Banking Ombudsman for deficient services or to invoke the 2019 Act.

Only judicial interpretation in the course of time will clarify how these overlapping provisions can be reconciled with each other.

Legislation may be out of scope of the powers of the Government:

Concerns have been raised about over-delegation under the 2019 Act. The Central government is empowered to make rules inter alia on ‘any matter which is to be, or may be, prescribed’. [xx] Use of the term ‘may be’ gives unbridled power to the Central government to prescribe rules for matters which may be remotely connected to consumer protection. For instance, the Draft Rules framed by the government under the 2019 Act are beyond the Act’s scope. [xxi] The 2019 Act is enacted to safeguard consumer interests, and availability of discounted products online is one of the major interests of consumers in India. How can the Rules then prohibit e-commerce entities from discounting product prices in the name of consumer interests? This provision, in fact, protects interests of offline retailers and hence appears to be a colorable exercise of power.

Conclusion:

The 2019 Act and the Draft Rules have been welcomed by Confederation of All India Traders (CAIT). However, they may hamper ease of doing business and hence the growth of e-commerce startups in India. Existing e-commerce giants might find themselves in limbo while complying with ambiguous and overlapping provisions under the 2019 Act. Verifying the authenticity of goods will compel coordination/ information-sharing with respective trademark owners, requiring additional investment in capital and human resources. In this light, the 2019 Act seems to be disproportionally harsh on the e-commerce giants and passes the burden of due diligence liability from consumers/ buyers to the sellers. Admittedly, provisions against unfair contracts, on product liability and data protection make the 2019 Act a salutary enactment, and represent empowerment of e-consumers against whimsical policies of the e-commerce companies. It is important that the government, in exercise of its rule-making powers, refrains from making rules which impose impractical compliance burden on the e-commerce businesses. Successful implementation of the 2019 Act is the key to effective consumer protection, and the government must lubricate its implementation by notifying the Draft Rules at the earliest.

(The views and opinions expressed in this article are author’s own and do not necessarily reflect the official policy or position of the Legal Aid Society, Campus Law Centre, University of Delhi.)

[i] Government of India, Ministry of Consumer Affairs, Food & Public Distribution, “Landmark Consumer Protection Bill, 2019 gets Parliamentary approval”, Press Information Bureau, Aug. 6, 2019, available at: https://pib.gov.in/newsite/PrintRelease.aspx?relid=192499 (last visited on Jan. 29, 2020).
[ii] M.M.K. Sardana, “Evolution Of E‐Commerce In India: Challenges Ahead (Part 1)”, ISID Discussion Notes, 2014, available at: http://isid.org.in/pdf/DN1407.pdf (last visited on Jan. 29, 2020).
[iii] Press Trust of India ,“E-commerce to be covered under Consumer Protection Act”, The Business Standard, Dec. 2, 2014, available at: https://www.business-standard.com/article/pti-stories/e-commerce-covered-under-consumer-protection-act-114120200686_1.html (last modified on Dec. 2, 2014).
[iv] Consumer Protection Act, 2019 (Act 35 of 2019), s. 94 read with s. 101(2) (zg).
[v] Government of India, Ministry of Consumer Affairs, Food & Public Distribution, F. No J-10/1/2019-CPU, Nov. 11, 2019, available at: https://consumeraffairs.nic.in/draft-rule (last visited on Feb.3, 2020).
[vi] Organization of Economic Cooperation and Development, “Addressing the Tax Challenges of the Digital Economy”, 2014 , available at: https://www.oecd-ilibrary.org/docserver/9789264218789-7-en.pdf?expires=1582453049&id=id&accname=guest&checksum=6EAAA6A22811922843280D2F7412BA17 (last visited on Feb. 23, 2020)
[vii] CS (COMM) 344/2018.
[viii] Greenman, v. Yuba Power Products, 59 Cal.2d 57 (1963).
[ix] Supra note 4, s. 2(34).
[x] Supra note 4, s. 2(22).
[xi] The Information Technology Act, 2000 (Act 21 of 2000), s. 79.
[xii] Supra note 7 at 56, 62, 63.
[xiii] Supra note 4, s. 2(24)(ii).
[xiv] Supra note 4, s. 21(2).
[xv] Sarthak Sarin, “The new consumer protection act decoded: What will be its impact on the e-commerce sector?”, CNBC TV 18, Nov. 6, 2019, available at: https://www.cnbctv18.com/views/the-new-consumer-protection-act-decoded-what-will-be-its-impact-on-the-e-commerce-sector-4646791.htm (last modified on Nov. 6, 2019).
[xvi] Supra note 4, s. 21(6).
[xvii] Supra note 4, s. 2(28).
[xviii] Supra note 4, s. 2(47)(ix).
[xix] “The Consumer Protection Act, 2019”, Ikigai Law, Sep. 9, 2019, available at: https://www.ikigailaw.com/the-consumer-protection-act-2019/#acceptLicense (last visited on Feb. 23, 2020).
[xx] Supra note 4, s. 101(2) (zj).
[xxi] Ashwin Mathew and Nayanika Majumdar, “Not discounting consumer protection”, The Financial Express, Dec. 27, 2019, available at: https://www.financialexpress.com/opinion/not-discounting-consumer-protection/1805001/ (last visited on Feb. 5, 2020).

3,700 Comments

  1. Meds information leaflet. Short-Term Effects.
    synthroid
    Best what you want to know about drugs. Get here.

  2. Medication information. Drug Class.
    singulair
    Everything information about drugs. Read here.

  3. purchase plavix online clopidogrel 75 mg canada how much is plavix medication

  4. Medication information for patients. Brand names.
    amoxil buy
    All what you want to know about medicament. Get here.

  5. dapoxetine 30 price in india dapoxetine online dapoxetine uk pharmacy

  6. Medicine information sheet. Effects of Drug Abuse.
    proscar without dr prescription
    Some information about medicines. Get information here.

  7. Drug information leaflet. Short-Term Effects.
    neurontin medication
    Everything trends of drug. Get information here.

  8. Medicine information sheet. What side effects?
    proscar sale
    Some trends of drug. Get information now.

  9. Meds information sheet. What side effects?
    xenical tablets
    All about meds. Read now.

  10. Drug information. Generic Name.
    colchicine medication
    All what you want to know about medicament. Get information here.

  11. Pills information for patients. Effects of Drug Abuse.
    abilify
    Actual trends of pills. Get information here.

  12. Drug information. What side effects?
    proscar sale
    Actual trends of medicament. Get here.

  13. Medication information leaflet. What side effects?
    synthroid
    All information about medicine. Get here.

  14. Drugs information. Drug Class.
    cialis
    Best news about medicines. Get information here.

  15. loperamide purchase loperamide price loperamide pills

  16. cheapest generic bactrim (sulfamethoxazole / trimethoprim) without a persription generic bactrim for sale bactrim ds price

  17. Drug information for patients. Effects of Drug Abuse.
    celebrex
    Some trends of medicines. Read now.

  18. What are the 3 major adverse reactions with antibiotics | azithromycin over the counter at walgreens
    So, what is a Z-pack actually? Unfortunately, many patients don’t know or aren’t told that the “Z” in Zithromax stands for azithromycin, which is a powerful macrolide antibiotic. All medicines in this class work by stopping bacteria reproduction, eventually killing the population, and curing the infection.

  19. Drugs information sheet. Cautions.
    clomid
    Everything information about medicine. Read here.

  20. Medication information sheet. Generic Name.
    neurontin tablet
    Everything news about medicine. Read information now.

  21. Pills information. Drug Class.
    lyrica
    Everything news about pills. Get information here.

  22. Drug information. Long-Term Effects.
    fosamax
    All about drug. Get information now.

  23. Drugs information leaflet. Generic Name.
    generic cytotec
    Everything trends of medication. Get information here.

  24. can i take metronidazole without food metronidazole cream cost flagyl for dogs

  25. Drugs information for patients. Effects of Drug Abuse.
    promethazine medication
    Actual what you want to know about medication. Get information now.

  26. You actually stated it very well!

  27. Medication information sheet. Long-Term Effects.
    zoloft
    Everything what you want to know about medicine. Get information now.

  28. pharmacy drug store online no rx
    https://canadianpharmacysaver.com/
    [url=https://canadianpharmacysaver.com/]price medication[/url]

  29. Medicine information. Short-Term Effects.
    strattera brand name
    Best news about medicines. Read information now.

  30. Drugs information sheet. Generic Name.
    clomid
    Actual what you want to know about drugs. Read now.

  31. Medicament prescribing information. Effects of Drug Abuse.
    neurontin without a prescription
    Actual trends of medicament. Read information here.

  32. Meds information sheet. Brand names.
    nexium
    All what you want to know about medicament. Read information here.

  33. Drug information leaflet. Drug Class.
    maxalt
    Some information about medicines. Read here.

  34. Meds information. Drug Class.
    pregabalin
    Some news about drug. Get now.

  35. Medicament prescribing information. Drug Class.
    neurontin buy
    Actual about drug. Get here.

  36. Medicine information for patients. Drug Class.
    how to get amoxil
    Some what you want to know about medicines. Read information here.

  37. Pills information for patients. What side effects?
    buy abilify
    Actual information about meds. Read information now.

  38. Medicament information. Short-Term Effects.
    cialis super active
    Actual news about meds. Read here.

  39. Meds information leaflet. Short-Term Effects.
    levaquin cost
    Best information about drugs. Read here.

  40. Medicines information. Effects of Drug Abuse.
    promethazine
    Actual about drug. Get information now.

  41. cheap leflunomide leflunomide united kingdom leflunomide medication

  42. Drugs information for patients. Generic Name.
    prednisone pills
    Best information about medicines. Get here.

  43. Medicine information leaflet. What side effects?
    where buy avodart
    Actual about drug. Read now.

  44. Medicament prescribing information. What side effects can this medication cause?
    lisinopril without prescription
    Actual what you want to know about pills. Read information now.

  45. flagyl 250 mg suspension flagyl cost walgreens flagyl 500 mg side effects

  46. Meds information leaflet. Short-Term Effects.
    cost of baclofen
    Everything about pills. Read now.

  47. Pills information for patients. Brand names.
    effexor
    Best news about drug. Read now.

  48. Drugs information. What side effects can this medication cause?
    cheap flagyl
    Everything information about medicines. Get now.

  49. Drugs prescribing information. Drug Class.
    paxil
    Some news about medicines. Get now.

  50. Drug information leaflet. What side effects?
    cialis super active
    Some news about drugs. Read here.

  51. Drug prescribing information. Long-Term Effects.
    motrin
    Everything trends of drugs. Read information here.

  52. Medicine information sheet. Short-Term Effects.
    neurontin
    All news about medicines. Get now.

  53. Medicament information for patients. Long-Term Effects.
    maxalt
    All news about medicine. Get information here.

  54. Medication information for patients. What side effects can this medication cause?
    lopressor
    Some information about medicines. Read information here.

  55. Incredible a good deal of superb knowledge!

    Have a look at my page – http://connersyqe859.theburnward.com/the-benefits-of-casino

  56. Medication prescribing information. What side effects?
    cytotec prices
    Everything news about meds. Read here.

  57. Pills information for patients. Brand names.
    proscar rx
    Some trends of drug. Get here.

  58. Drugs information sheet. Drug Class.
    prednisone
    Best about medicament. Get here.

  59. Medicament information leaflet. Cautions.
    viagra
    Actual what you want to know about drugs. Get information now.

  60. Good write-up, I’m regular visitor of one’s site, maintain up the excellent operate, and It is going to be a regular visitor for a lengthy time.

  61. Medication information sheet. Cautions.
    rx fluoxetine
    Actual trends of meds. Read now.

  62. Medicines prescribing information. Generic Name.
    clomid
    Everything what you want to know about medicine. Read information here.

  63. Medicament information sheet. Long-Term Effects.
    celebrex
    All trends of medicines. Read information here.

  64. Meds information. What side effects can this medication cause?
    maxalt without dr prescription
    Everything news about medicine. Read information here.

  65. Medicament prescribing information. Drug Class.
    neurontin generic
    Some trends of medicine. Read here.

  66. Meds information leaflet. Effects of Drug Abuse.
    celebrex
    Actual information about medicament. Read information here.

  67. Drugs information for patients. Long-Term Effects.
    trazodone
    Everything what you want to know about drugs. Get here.

  68. Medicament information sheet. Generic Name.
    pregabalin generic
    All about medicines. Read here.

  69. Medicament information sheet. Effects of Drug Abuse.
    seroquel order
    All what you want to know about pills. Read information now.

  70. Medicines prescribing information. Brand names.
    cialis soft
    Best what you want to know about drugs. Get here.

  71. Medicines information for patients. Brand names.
    mobic
    All information about drug. Read here.

  72. Pills information leaflet. Drug Class.
    lyrica cost
    All about meds. Get here.

  73. The most current chapter of Arizona gambling has been the legalization of sports betting and on line fantasy sports in 2021.

    Stop by my webpage: https://ulzzang.us/7-questions-and-answers-to-what-is-the-best-casino-gamble/

  74. buy z-pack from canada
    Zithromax should not be used in people with liver or kidney disease, as it can cause these conditions to worsen. It can also interact with other medications, including antacids, blood thinners, and certain antibiotics.

  75. Medicines information for patients. Brand names.
    viagra soft
    Some news about meds. Read here.

  76. Medicines information for patients. Drug Class.
    singulair
    Everything about medicament. Read now.

  77. Pills information for patients. What side effects can this medication cause?
    prednisone rx
    Actual trends of meds. Get information now.

  78. buy azithromycin cheap use of Azithromycin side effects of Zithromax z pak

  79. Medication information leaflet. Cautions.
    effexor without insurance
    Some information about drug. Read information now.

  80. You made the point.

    Stop by my web blog :: https://antivol-pour-velo.com/

  81. Medicament information for patients. Brand names.
    rx prozac
    Actual what you want to know about pills. Read here.

  82. Medicines prescribing information. Effects of Drug Abuse.
    propecia
    Actual news about drug. Read now.

  83. Hello.This article was really remarkable, especially because I was investigating for thoughts on this matter last Thursday.

  84. Drugs information. Short-Term Effects.
    where can i get fluoxetine
    Actual what you want to know about pills. Get information now.

  85. Medication information leaflet. Drug Class.
    flibanserina
    All trends of medicines. Get now.

  86. Medicine information for patients. What side effects?
    prednisone without dr prescription
    Best about medicine. Get here.

  87. Medicines information for patients. Effects of Drug Abuse.
    zovirax without dr prescription
    Some about drugs. Read information now.

  88. Medicines information for patients. Short-Term Effects.
    lopressor
    All what you want to know about drugs. Read information here.

  89. Thanks for sharing. I read many of your blog posts, cool, your blog is very good.

  90. Priligy online
    When buying dapoxetine, it is important to consider the total cost of treatment, including any potential co-payments or deductibles required by your insurance plan.

  91. Medicine information for patients. Effects of Drug Abuse.
    prednisone cheap
    All information about medicines. Get information here.

  92. The first-line treatment on the side of pneumonia in adults is macrolide antibiotics, like Azithromycin for dogs or erythromycin. In children, the first-line treatment pro bacterial pneumonia is typically amoxicillin.

  93. Terrific information, Thanks.

    Review my web blog https://www.afrique54.net/contactez-nous/

  94. Meds information. Generic Name.
    zovirax
    Best trends of medicines. Get information here.

  95. Meds information leaflet. Long-Term Effects.
    singulair
    Best information about medicines. Get information here.

  96. Medicines information sheet. Brand names.
    viagra with fluoxetine medication
    Everything news about medicines. Get information now.

  97. desmopressinmg no prescription cost of desmopressin mcg desmopressin mcg tablet

  98. Drug information. Generic Name.
    neurontin generics
    Some news about drugs. Get here.

  99. etodolac pharmacy etodolac cost etodolac without a doctor prescription

  100. Medication information sheet. Drug Class.
    flibanserina
    All trends of meds. Get now.

  101. Medication information. Generic Name.
    get fluoxetine
    All what you want to know about medication. Get here.

  102. Drugs information. Effects of Drug Abuse.
    cephalexin
    All about pills. Read now.

  103. Medicine information sheet. Short-Term Effects.
    flibanserin
    Best about medicine. Get information now.

  104. Medication information leaflet. Effects of Drug Abuse.
    zithromax otc
    Some what you want to know about drug. Get information now.

  105. Medication information leaflet. Long-Term Effects.
    cephalexin
    Everything trends of medication. Read information now.

  106. Medicine prescribing information. Cautions.
    where can i get lopressor
    Everything what you want to know about meds. Read now.

  107. Medicines information leaflet. What side effects can this medication cause?
    lyrica cost
    All trends of drug. Read information here.

  108. Medication information for patients. What side effects can this medication cause?
    lioresal tablet
    Everything news about drug. Get information now.

  109. Drug information sheet. Generic Name.
    cialis
    Actual what you want to know about medicines. Get information now.

  110. Your article helped me a lot, is there any more related content? Thanks!

  111. Medicament information. Cautions.
    fosamax price
    Some news about pills. Read now.

  112. Medicine information leaflet. Short-Term Effects.
    viagra
    Everything trends of medicine. Read now.

  113. Pills prescribing information. Effects of Drug Abuse.
    how to buy cephalexin
    All trends of drug. Get here.

  114. Meds information leaflet. Brand names.
    where to buy zithromax
    Everything information about medicine. Read information here.

  115. Medicament information sheet. Effects of Drug Abuse.
    can you get avodart
    Best about drug. Get information here.

  116. Pills information sheet. Generic Name.
    get lioresal
    Best about medicine. Get here.

  117. Drug information. Brand names.
    cost of cialis
    All information about drugs. Read here.

  118. Medicine information sheet. Brand names.
    zovirax without rx
    Some information about medicines. Read here.

  119. A Z-pack is a regimen of recipe antibiotics (z pack antibiotic from mexico) euphemistic pre-owned to expound on bacterial infections. Antibiotics, including the Z-pack, do not remedying viruses, which are the compel of most colds and flush with bronchitis. Antibiotics, strikingly the Z-pack, are commonly over-prescribed when they are not needed.

  120. Medicament information sheet. Generic Name.
    where to buy flagyl
    Best information about pills. Read here.

  121. cialis samples canada https://wwcillisa.com/ cialis bathtub

  122. buy sildenafil pills https://vivigrix.com/ generic sildenafil 20 mg cost

  123. You revealed this superbly.

    Feel free to surf to my web blog; http://www.allonsdelavant.fr/

  124. I’ve been absent for a while, but now I remember why I used to love this site. Thank you, I’ll try and check back more often. How frequently you update your site?

  125. [url=https://hydrochlorothiazide.cyou/]cost of hydrochlorothiazide 12.5 mg[/url]

  126. Medication information leaflet. What side effects?
    paxil
    Best information about medicine. Get information now.

  127. hyzaar 12,5mg without prescription hyzaar otc hyzaar 12,5 mg without a doctor prescription

  128. Pills prescribing information. What side effects?
    cialis with dapoxetine brand name
    Best trends of drug. Read here.

  129. Pills information leaflet. Effects of Drug Abuse.
    flibanserin buy
    Some trends of medicament. Get now.

  130. Medicines prescribing information. Short-Term Effects.
    paxil
    Actual trends of drugs. Read information here.

  131. Your article helped me a lot, is there any more related content? Thanks!

  132. What sleeping position makes your stomach flat and Zithromax class?

  133. Medicines information sheet. Long-Term Effects.
    cheap flibanserin
    All about medication. Get information now.

  134. Medicine information sheet. What side effects can this medication cause?
    neurontin
    Actual what you want to know about medicines. Read here.

  135. Medication information for patients. Short-Term Effects.
    rx deltasone
    All what you want to know about pills. Read information now.

  136. You mentioned it well.

    Here is my web site … http://www.lesmotsdits.fr/

  137. Medicines information for patients. Drug Class.
    flagyl without insurance
    All news about medication. Read information now.

  138. You actually said that exceptionally well!

    my blog; http://www.reflets-du-monde.fr/

  139. Medicines information leaflet. Short-Term Effects.
    lioresal
    Best information about meds. Get information here.

  140. Wonderful stuff Thank you.

    Also visit my website http://www.ouverturedesprit.fr/

  141. Medicine information for patients. What side effects?
    flibanserin
    Actual news about drugs. Get information now.

  142. Seriously many of terrific advice!

    my webpage … http://www.cap-sur-demain.fr/

  143. Drug information for patients. Generic Name.
    zofran medication
    All trends of drugs. Read information here.

  144. You actually said that effectively!

    My homepage – http://www.vivre-le-monde.fr/

  145. Medication information. Drug Class.
    abilify
    Everything about pills. Get now.

  146. freeb resume help writing a cover letter for a job customer service team leader resume

  147. Medicine prescribing information. Long-Term Effects.
    neurontin for sale
    Some what you want to know about medicines. Get information now.

  148. Drugs information. Long-Term Effects.
    cialis otc
    Best news about medication. Read information here.

  149. Fantastic forum posts, Many thanks.

    My blog post: http://www.evolutionmondiale.fr/

  150. Medicament information. Effects of Drug Abuse.
    maxalt tablets
    Some information about medicine. Get information here.

  151. Drugs information for patients. Effects of Drug Abuse.
    rx zithromax
    All news about medicine. Read now.

  152. Medicine information sheet. What side effects can this medication cause?
    buy paxil
    Everything about drugs. Get now.

  153. Do you have a spam problem on this blog; I also am a blogger, and I was curious about your situation; many of us have developed some nice methods and we are looking to trade strategies with others, be sure to shoot me an e-mail if interested.

    My web site: https://bhd-films.com/art/john-veen-quote/

  154. Medicines information sheet. Generic Name.
    flagyl pills
    Everything news about medication. Get here.

  155. Enjoyed examining this, very good stuff, appreciate it. “Curiosity killed the cat, but for a while I was a suspect.” by Steven Wright.

  156. Drugs information. Short-Term Effects.
    neurontin
    All about drugs. Get information here.

  157. Drugs prescribing information. What side effects?
    furosemide generics
    Actual about drug. Read information now.

  158. Medicine information. Short-Term Effects.
    singulair
    Some information about medicine. Get information now.

  159. Medicine information sheet. What side effects can this medication cause?
    cleocin order
    All what you want to know about meds. Get information now.

  160. I like this internet site because so much utile material on here : D.

  161. Pills information for patients. Effects of Drug Abuse.
    levaquin
    Everything what you want to know about medicines. Read information here.

  162. Drugs information sheet. Short-Term Effects.
    zithromax medication
    Best what you want to know about meds. Get information here.

  163. Drug information. What side effects can this medication cause?
    cheap seroquel
    All about pills. Read here.

  164. Medicines information leaflet. What side effects?
    flibanserin
    Everything trends of medication. Read here.

  165. Medicines prescribing information. Brand names.
    doxycycline medication
    All news about medicament. Read here.

  166. Drug information. Effects of Drug Abuse.
    where can i buy propecia
    Best trends of meds. Read here.

  167. Drug information for patients. Drug Class.
    buy propranolol
    Some information about medicine. Read now.

  168. Medicines information. What side effects can this medication cause?
    pregabalin online
    Everything trends of meds. Read information here.

  169. договор на техническое обслуживание авто

    Техническое обслуживание машинного средства – целый комплекс предупредительных граней, что сосредоточены сверху устранение поломок.
    техническое обслуживание авто это

  170. Medicament information for patients. What side effects?
    zovirax
    Some about meds. Read here.

  171. An interesting discussion is worth comment. I think that you should write more on this topic, it might not be a taboo subject but generally people are not enough to speak on such topics. To the next. Cheers

  172. Medicines prescribing information. Short-Term Effects.
    pregabalin without insurance
    Some trends of drug. Get information here.

  173. Medicament information sheet. Generic Name.
    doxycycline no prescription
    Everything trends of pills. Read here.

  174. Pills information sheet. Short-Term Effects.
    tadalafil
    Everything information about medicines. Get information now.

  175. Medicine prescribing information. Drug Class.
    prednisone cheap
    Everything trends of medicament. Get now.

  176. Medicament information sheet. Long-Term Effects.
    flagyl
    Actual what you want to know about medicament. Get here.

  177. Drug information leaflet. What side effects can this medication cause?
    augmentin
    Some news about medication. Get now.

  178. Medicines information. Cautions.
    cheap zithromax
    All what you want to know about medicine. Read now.

  179. aldactone 25mg tablets aldactone 100 mg tablets aldactone tablets

  180. Drugs information for patients. Short-Term Effects.
    lisinopril
    Actual what you want to know about medication. Read now.

  181. Many thanks! I enjoy this.

  182. Pills information. Long-Term Effects.
    cytotec
    Best news about meds. Read now.

  183. Drug information sheet. Drug Class.
    generic strattera
    Some information about medicines. Get information here.

  184. Meds prescribing information. What side effects?
    how can i get cipro
    Actual trends of drug. Get information now.

  185. Helpful content, Thanks a lot.

    Review my blog; https://pawtounes.fr/top-10/

  186. Drug information leaflet. What side effects?
    cost doxycycline
    Some what you want to know about medicament. Read information now.

  187. Drug information for patients. Drug Class.
    cleocin generic
    All news about medication. Get now.

  188. tadalafil cialis 5mg https://tadafilax.com/ tadalafil 100mg price

  189. Medicine prescribing information. What side effects?
    cetirizine
    Best information about medicament. Get information here.

  190. Thanks! Good stuff.

    Feel free to surf to my web-site … https://www.ebay.fr/itm/185844210751

  191. Meds information for patients. What side effects can this medication cause?
    levaquin order
    Actual news about medicines. Read here.

  192. Drugs information leaflet. Drug Class.
    how to buy maxalt
    Actual what you want to know about pills. Get information here.

  193. kamagra senza ricetta in farmacia: gel per erezione in farmacia – viagra originale in 24 ore contrassegno

  194. Meds information leaflet. Cautions.
    levaquin
    Best information about drug. Get now.

  195. Medication information. Generic Name.
    lioresal otc
    Some trends of meds. Get information here.

  196. Drugs information leaflet. Long-Term Effects.
    cetirizine
    Best about drug. Read now.

  197. Good posts Cheers!

    Also visit my web site … http://www.linknova.fr/

  198. Medication information for patients. What side effects can this medication cause?
    colchicine
    Everything information about pills. Read here.

  199. Pills information leaflet. Drug Class.
    cost mobic
    All news about drug. Read information now.

  200. Medication information sheet. Short-Term Effects.
    protonix prices
    Best what you want to know about medicine. Get here.

  201. ivermectin stromectol ivermectin gold https://stromectole.com

  202. Medicines information for patients. Generic Name.
    avodart cheap
    Some what you want to know about meds. Get information now.

  203. Drug information. Effects of Drug Abuse.
    buy generic med info pharm
    Everything information about medication. Get information now.

  204. imdur online pharmacy imdur 40mg nz order imdur 20 mg

  205. Drug information sheet. Long-Term Effects.
    diltiazem
    Everything news about drug. Get information now.

  206. Meds information sheet. Short-Term Effects.
    rx prednisone
    Everything news about drugs. Read here.

  207. Medicine prescribing information. Effects of Drug Abuse.
    levaquin generics
    Best what you want to know about medication. Get now.

  208. Medicine information. Cautions.
    lyrica
    All trends of medicine. Get information here.

  209. fexofenadine tablets cheap fexofenadine fexofenadine usa

  210. Здравствуйте! Позвоните пожалуйста, интересует товар с вашего сайта.
    89686803080

  211. Meds information. Drug Class.
    baclofen
    Everything news about medicament. Read information here.

  212. Drugs prescribing information. Short-Term Effects.
    motrin
    Everything information about drug. Get information now.

  213. Medicines information for patients. What side effects?
    lyrica
    All trends of pills. Read now.

  214. Medicines information for patients. Brand names.
    buy prograf
    Best information about drugs. Read now.

  215. Permanent makeup

    A immaculate mien is a undertake of self-confidence. It’s hard to contest with this, but how to take care of yourself if there is sorely not adequately time after this? Lasting makeup is a wonderful explanation!
    Permanent makeup

  216. Продвижение сайтов

    Комплексный ход буква СЕО — этто эвентуальность обеспечить максимальный эффект интернет-продвижения.
    Продвижение сайтов

  217. [url=http://nolvadex.gives/]tamoxifen price in canada[/url]

  218. Medication information leaflet. Short-Term Effects.
    cephalexin
    All about medicine. Get here.

  219. amateur double penetration
  220. Drug prescribing information. Effects of Drug Abuse.
    lopressor
    Best news about drugs. Get information now.

  221. Pills information leaflet. Cautions.
    where can i buy levaquin
    Best what you want to know about pills. Get now.

  222. Drug information. Generic Name.
    cost levaquin
    Best about medicament. Get information here.

  223. Drugs information sheet. Generic Name.
    viagra without rx
    Everything trends of medicine. Get information here.

  224. Meds information sheet. What side effects?
    amoxil medication
    Everything about meds. Get now.

  225. Medicines information. What side effects?
    retrovir buy
    All information about medication. Get information here.

  226. вывод из запоя

    Темный постояннодействующий стационар в течение Москве. Я мухой а также безопасно оборвем запой любой тяжести. Прогрессивные палаты различного уровня комфорта.
    вывод из запоя

  227. наркоклиника

    Коммерческие наркологическая клиника занимается излечением, реабилитацией связей в течение Москве анонимно. Наркологическая шефство на частном центре.
    наркоклиника

  228. Medicament prescribing information. Effects of Drug Abuse.
    retrovir buy
    Best about meds. Read information now.

  229. Pills prescribing information. What side effects?
    lioresal
    Some about drug. Read now.

  230. how to purchase trazodone trazodone no prescription trazodone canada

  231. azithromycin z pack instructions can i buy azithromycin over the counter can you purchase azithromycin over the counter

  232. pharmacie en ligne cialis cialis generique prix en pharmacie tadalafil 5 mg sandoz prix

  233. Medicines information leaflet. Short-Term Effects.
    protonix
    All trends of medicine. Get information here.

  234. Pills information. Drug Class.
    levaquin medication
    Actual trends of medicines. Read now.

  235. Drugs information sheet. Effects of Drug Abuse.
    prednisone
    Some information about medicines. Read here.

  236. купить батут с сеткой

    Разве что ваша милость шарите прочные батуты для дачи, то поворотите чуткость на продукцию компашки Hasttings. ЯЗЫК нас вы отыщете уличные детские батуты капля уступчатый и еще хаой сетью числом вразумительной цене. Пишущий эти строки тоже делаем отличное предложение плетенку чтобы удобства покупки и еще доставку числом Москве, Санкт-петербургу и старый и малый России в течение подарок умереть и не встать время (резервный! Уточняйте тонкости язык нашего менеджера.
    купить батут с сеткой

  237. Medicament information leaflet. Short-Term Effects.
    colchicine without dr prescription
    Everything trends of drug. Get here.

  238. Drug information. What side effects?
    doxycycline buy
    Everything information about medicines. Get information now.

  239. Drug prescribing information. Generic Name.
    doxycycline
    Some what you want to know about drugs. Get information here.

  240. Medicament information for patients. Long-Term Effects.
    fluoxetine buy
    Some about medication. Read now.

  241. Medicament information leaflet. Short-Term Effects.
    generic lisinopril
    Everything information about meds. Read now.

  242. Виза в Финляндию

    Возбуждая начиная с. ant. до 30 сентября 2022 года, Финляндия не разрешила гражданам России предмостье в течение державу капля туристической целью посредством наружную границу Шенгена. Чтоб попасть на Финляндию, нужно быть хозяином специальные причины.
    Виза в Финляндию

  243. I quite like reading through a post that will make men and women think. Also, thanks for allowing me to comment!

    My homepage :: http://dssurl.com/6flQ

  244. Medicines information leaflet. Brand names.
    amoxil
    Everything what you want to know about medicines. Read here.

  245. can i buy azithromycin over the counter 1000 mg azithromycin z pack 500 mg instructions

  246. Medicine information for patients. Drug Class.
    propecia medication
    Actual news about drug. Read here.

  247. plaquenil 200 mg plaquenil for lupus hydroxychloroquine zinc and zithromax

  248. With thanks. I appreciate it!

    Here is my site … https://bit.ly/3KnD5fl

  249. Pills information sheet. Effects of Drug Abuse.
    furosemide
    Actual trends of meds. Read information now.

  250. Drugs information sheet. Effects of Drug Abuse.
    cheap furosemide
    All trends of drugs. Read information here.

  251. Meds prescribing information. What side effects?
    cheap prograf
    All trends of pills. Read now.

  252. Тепловизоры

    Тепловизор – электроустройство, которое через слово приобретают для охоты, для военных, чтобы власти за тепловым состоянием объектов. Это потребованная электропродукция, разрабатываемая на основании передовых технологий да один-другой учетом стандартов.
    Тепловизоры

  253. Medicines information sheet. Drug Class.
    levaquin without prescription
    All what you want to know about medication. Read information here.

  254. Drug information leaflet. Long-Term Effects.
    maxalt
    Actual news about medicament. Read information now.

  255. Medicine information sheet. Drug Class.
    where buy minocycline
    Some information about medicine. Get now.

  256. Everything is very open and very clear explanation of issues. was truly information. Your website is very useful. Thanks for sharing.

  257. This is a very good tips especially to those new to blogosphere, brief and accurate information… Thanks for sharing this one. A must read article.

  258. Drugs information for patients. Drug Class.
    amoxil medication
    Actual news about medication. Get information here.

  259. sildenafil pharmacy sildenafil tablets where to buy sildenafil

  260. Good info. Lucky me I reach on your website by accident, I bookmarked it.

  261. fake uk citizenship generator
  262. Drugs information for patients. Generic Name.
    order prednisone
    Some what you want to know about drug. Read information here.

  263. Pills information leaflet. Generic Name.
    cephalexin for sale
    Everything information about medicament. Read now.

  264. This is a topic close to my heart cheers, where are your contact details though?

  265. Medication information leaflet. Drug Class.
    diltiazem
    All news about pills. Read here.

  266. Pills information sheet. Drug Class.
    maxalt
    All trends of meds. Read now.

  267. I’d like to find out more? I’d love to find out more details.

    My web site; https://www.nlvl.wiki/index.php/Use_Verdict_For_Healthy_Weight_Loss

  268. fake caribbean citizenship card
  269. The blog was how do i say it… relevant, finally something that helped me. Thanks

  270. Meds prescribing information. Effects of Drug Abuse.
    prasugrel
    Everything information about medicine. Read information now.

  271. Medication information leaflet. Brand names.
    maxalt
    Everything trends of pills. Read here.

  272. Your style is so unique compared to many other people. Thank you for publishing when you have the opportunity,Guess I will just make this bookmarked.2

  273. plaquenil blood thinner order hydroxychloroquine mylan hydroxychloroquine

  274. экспресс займ без отказа онлайн на карту

    Предпочти фидуциарий а также получите деньги на карту уже вследствие 15 минутная Займ онлайн сверху карту именно здесь.
    займ на карту 2023

  275. calcium carbonate over the counter how to purchase calcium carbonate 500 mg calcium carbonate 500mg australia

  276. Pills information for patients. What side effects can this medication cause?
    cialis super active
    Everything news about medicine. Read now.

  277. Займы с 18 лет

    Когда приходит время взять ссуда, Нам что поделаешь элита, стократ перерости, И конца-краю утратить собственные деньги что ни попало, Но кае же хоть найти помощь?
    Займы с 18 лет

  278. Medicament information for patients. Drug Class.
    buy generic cleocin
    Best trends of drugs. Read here.

  279. Prescription bumf sheet. What side effects? pfizer viagra pill All tidings upon drug. Review here.

  280. where can i buy lisinopril 5 mg lisinopril without a prescription where can i buy lisinopril

  281. ivermectin contraindications stromectol 3mg information http://stromectolverb.com

  282. I was just seeking this info for some time. After 6 hours of continuous Googleing, finally I got it in your site. I wonder what’s the lack of Google strategy that do not rank this kind of informative web sites in top of the list. Usually the top web sites are full of garbage.

    Also visit my web blog :: http://barbg.com/__media__/js/netsoltrademark.php?d=www.virtuosal.com%2Fforum%2Fviewtopic.php%3Fid%3D337870

  283. Тепловизор

    Термовизор – оптический прибор, яже предназначается чтобы обнаружения объектов на расстоянии.
    Тепловизор

  284. proscar cost in india proscar prescription r pro cars

  285. thesis software thesis outline example abstract thesis

  286. thesis builder non thesis masters how long should a thesis be

  287. can a thesis be at the end of an essay essay thesis examples literary thesis

  288. My brother suggested I might like this web site. He was entirely right. This post truly made my day. You can not imagine simply how much time I had spent for this information! Thanks!

    my web page … https://www.bindlestiffprivatetours.com/incorporating-a-technology-startup/

  289. Medicines information sheet. What side effects?
    cheap lisinopril
    All information about medicament. Get information here.

  290. Medication prescribing information. Drug Class.
    pregabalin
    Best about medicine. Get information now.

  291. thesis writing research paper thesis example cruel angel’s thesis full

  292. [url=https://kursy-po-seo-prodvizheniju-v-moskve.ru]продвижение сайтов обучение[/url]

    Основываем сайты маленький нулевой отметки: штучный Дизайн и лучшая Верстка. От визитки ут магазина. Разработка сайтов от $400. Под ключ.
    обучающий сайт продвижение

  293. [url=https://tamoxifena.online/]nolvadex 50mg[/url]

  294. Valuable posts. Thanks!
    help for writing essays essaypro essay typer english essay writing help

  295. Medicines information leaflet. Drug Class.
    lisinopril order
    All trends of medicines. Read now.

  296. Hi

    I absolutely love your blog and find most of your post’s to be exactly what I’m looking for. can you offer guest writers to write content for you personally? I wouldn’t mind producing a post or elaborating on many of the subjects you write in relation to here. Again, awesome blog!

    https://cutt.ly/U4fVpFe

    Best Regards
    adcardz.com/moneytraffic

  297. Pills information sheet. Short-Term Effects.
    levaquin brand name
    Actual what you want to know about drugs. Read now.

  298. Nicely put. Many thanks.
    buy research papers online help me with my research paper buy research papers online writing a proposal for your dissertation

  299. need help writing a essay best essay websites good essay writing service

  300. Thanks a lot. Valuable stuff!
    write your dissertation dissertation help service uk do my dissertation english dissertation help
    writing services for college papers scientific paper writing services b2b white paper writing service research paper writing service australia
    top rated essay writing websites https://phdthesisdissertation.com

  301. Permanent makeup

    Do you want to highlight your reasonable beauty? Then endless makeup is a eminent election! This is a custom performed by means of well-informed craftsmen who know all its subtleties.
    Permanent makeup

  302. Завод РТИ

    Используем на изготовлении пресс-формы, четвертое сословие гидравлические (а) также машинные, силуэт для создания покрышек а также резиновых изделий.
    Завод РТИ

  303. Regards. Ample postings!
    someone do my homework for me do my homework reddit do my autocad homework define linear motion laboratory experiences module 3_ do my homework

  304. Medicament information leaflet. What side effects can this medication cause?
    cefixime no prescription
    Actual trends of pills. Read information now.

  305. Pills information for patients. What side effects can this medication cause?
    lioresal
    Best information about medicine. Get information now.

  306. Kudos, Lots of content!
    write my essay in 1 hour how i became a better writer essay someone to write my essay how to write an about me bio for blog

  307. You actually mentioned it fantastically!
    doctoral dissertation writing help dissertation online literature review dissertation help phd research paper
    online paper writing service write paper service 4th grade essay writing worksheets professional essay writing services uk
    great writing 3 from great paragraphs to great essays https://writeadissertation.com

  308. essay on the help custom writing essay service help writing a compare and contrast essay

  309. Thanks a lot! I value this!
    doctoral dissertation writing help dissertation help online free buy dissertation paper find dissertations online

  310. You actually stated that adequately!
    paper writing service cost us based research paper writing service papers writing service research paper writing service reddit
    custom essay order admission essay help essay typer admission essay help
    essay custom writing https://customthesiswritingservice.com

  311. What are serious side effects of antibiotics ivermectin for swine – https://www.stromectoluk.com/