The Need for Consistent Transgender Policies in Sports

Legal Aid Society, Campus Law Centre, University of Delhi

The Need for Consistent Transgender Policies in Sports

April 26, 2022 Uncategorized 42

The Need for Consistent Transgender Policies in Sports

 

This Article has been written by Sneha Bhargava. The author is a second-year law student, pursuing B.A. LL.B. at O.P. Jindal Global University.

Introduction:

Transgender persons have historically been banned from participating in sports as they do not fall into society’s accepted male-female binary system. To participate in sports, they continue to face challenges like discrimination and banishment, forceful sex reassignment surgery, and hormone regulation. One of the major challenges is adhering to multiple policies, which are inconsistent and conflicting. The very incongruous nature of the policies for different sports at various levels has caused a lot of chaos and confusion, not to mention the added hardships to the transgender community. The question here is not about which sports policy is the best suited or which is the most discriminatory. It is rather about the hurdles these inconsistencies have caused, and the lack of consistent policies being created at a national and international level for transgender persons.

One of the early policies was the International Olympic Committee’s (IOC) Stockholm Policy of 2003, which allowed people to compete post a sex reassignment surgery followed by two years of hormone therapy. The amendment of 2015 scrapped the surgery but continued regulating testosterone levels. Currently, there exist numerous contradicting policies. For instance, while Ladies Professional Golf Association make either surgery or hormone regulation – or both, mandatory, the International Tennis Federation mandates a transwoman to have less than 5 nmol/L for at least 12 months – a longer requirement period based on evaluation, to determine whether 12 months is sufficient to minimise any advantages.

Chaos at International Level:

There are multiple international policies that are most conflicting and discriminatory.

For instance, The Football Association (FA) took out a policy on trans inclusion by allowing transsexuals to compete in their affirmed gender by contacting the FA to get clearance with a confidential conversation and details of evidence the FA would require. But when it comes specifically to trans players wishing to play in their affirmed sex, they have stated that they will consider applications for clearance on a case-by-case basis. The issue here is that since the specifics of the ‘case-to-case’ clearance procedure are not made public, there is no transparency. Proof consisting of medical information and records, blood testosterone and hormone treatment are deliberated upon in an individual review of trans athletes who have already undergone or are in the process of undergoing medical treatment. The FA’s policy for trans athletes in football document verifies the fact that the FA only considers those trans players who have already undergone hormone therapy, based on surpassing a certain hormone-based requirement as well as the maintenance of certain levels.

Additionally, if the trans athletes are from Australia, their applications must be provided to the FA’s Equality Manager and those who have not undergone hormone therapy would have their applications individually considered. This is because the Australian Football League released a gender diversity policy in August 2018 which used height, weight, vertical jump, etc. besides hormones as indicators of eligibility, which is again inconsistent with other policies in place. Even US Soccer Federation opens membership to all without discrimination but it does not apply this policy to professional leagues or the Federation’s National Teams programs.

Conflicting Policies in USA and Canada:

To better understand the obstacles faced by trans athletes, the author focuses on a hypothetical case from USA and Canada.

Gender self-declaration is the sole requirement to participate in sports in Canada, while U Sports has adopted the testosterone measures given by World Anti-Doping Agency, and the IOC has provided a specific range for a transwoman’s testosterone level. If, for example, we consider the case of a 15-year-old student diagnosed with gender dysphoria[1] – male at birth but identifying as female, living in Manitoba Canada, there would be several sets of inclusion parameters at different levels of sports in different geographic regions simultaneously. According to the Manitoba High School Athletics Association’s policy, she is free to compete on the girls’ teams in a safe and respectful environment, in any sport of her choice. Yet, if she pursues a college degree in Minnesota, USA, she would have to consume testosterone-blocking drugs for a year and sit out competitions in the meantime, while being administered tests to be eligible under the National Collegiate Athletics Association’s policy. Now if she proceeds to compete internationally, she would face problems again. She would have to follow the criteria set out by the IOC in order to participate in the Olympics. This is assuming the fact that she wants to compete in a sport that does not ban transgender persons or has made surgery mandatory. This is also assuming that she wants to compete in a single sport, at a single level, and not two or more sports, at various levels, since she would have to adhere to different regulations, ranging from producing different documents, maintaining her testosterone levels, having meetings with panels as well as continuous medical examinations by experts.

Discrimination in India:

Sex testing was introduced with a good conscience so as to particularly make sure that men do not masquerade as women to gain an advantage over athletes in sports. However, these tests have turned discriminatory, and unequal as well as they lack privacy as they are mainly conducted on females.

Santhi Soundarajan was stripped of her 2006 Asian Games silver medal after failing a sex verification test. The Indian Olympic Association proceeded to inform her that she was prohibited from competing any further, without even notifying her of the test she had failed. She was merely declared ineligible since she did not possess a woman’s sexual characteristics. Such tests are conducted without even informing the athletes. Dutee Chand was taken to a hospital to ascertain her gender without any information. Moreover, she got to know of the same through media.

These conditions violate the rights of the athletes. When they are subjected to such tests, particularly in public, they feel isolated and vulnerable, even depressed and suicidal, as was Santhi Soundarajan. The Right to Equality under Article 14 and the Right to Privacy under Article 21 of the Constitution of India is violated each time a doubt of gender arises for these athletes and they are forcefully subjected to these tests which are performed unknowingly at any point of time.

This is an even graver issue because the tests and qualifications required are different at different national and international levels. This means that an athlete may fail the sex verification test they are subjected to in one country, but may pass one in another country. A real-life example would be Ewa Klobukowska, an Olympian, who passed the mandatory sex test in Budapest but failed the one in Mexico.

The Constitution of India provides all sorts of rights such as education and health benefits to transgender persons, even prohibition against discrimination based on sex as a fundamental right under Article 15, yet the third gender continues to be ostracized. The focus of sex verification tests on trans females but not on trans males violates Articles 14 & 15, and the public scrutiny and discussion of the same violates the rights guaranteed by Article 21 to the Indian athletes.

Conclusion:

This shows that though policy development for transsexual persons is seemingly taking a step in the right direction, i.e. creating a consistent policy for trans athletes at National and International levels – the need of the hour. The presence of multiple overlapping yet inconsistent policies is leading to chaos. Ensuring fair play and equality of opportunities, without excluding anyone and harming the spirit of sport is an exigent task. Although there is a long way to go towards the acceptance and inclusion of transgender persons worldwide, the correction of these inconsistent policies would be the first step. Setting up a formal international committee that could create consistent laws and policies for transgender persons in the sporting community, and oversee the regulation of the same would count as making a huge stride in the correct direction. The creation of multiple incongruent policies causes more confusion and perplexity, than inclusivity and fair play. The aim of said committee would be to make sure the Rights of the athletes are not violated and all of them are treated equally, with no discrimination, and their privacy is maintained. It would create a healthy environment of inclusivity and fair play, rather than the violative and discriminatory one at present.

 

[1] Sarah Teetzel, Reflecting on Modern Sport in Ancient Olympia: Proceedings of the 2016 Meeting of the International Association for the Philosophy of Sport at the International Olympic Academy 161–170 (Parnassos Press, 2017).

42 Responses

  1. Shveta says:

    Very well written

  2. Shashi Bhargava says:

    I have gone through the whole article in detail and found it quite interesting and well researched.
    I wish the author all success and good luck.

  3. Rohan Bhargava says:

    Well written and articulated

  4. Dr Yogesh says:

    Nicely researched and written on a burning topic. Uniform international Policies are definitely needed for the same. Hope we see some concrete development in the same.

  5. I was pretty pleased to discover this great site. I need to to thank you for your time for this particularly fantastic read!! I definitely appreciated every part of it and I have you book marked to see new stuff on your blog

  6. Abelige says:

    It all comes down to the needs of your individual system buy cialis canada pharmacy

  7. heitinK says:

    4 , but the difference was not significant between treatment groups p 0 buy priligy

  8. advicky says:

    However, some mild and transient adverse drug reactions have been reported, including headache, dizziness, flushing, dyspepsia, back pain, myalgia, nasal congestion, and nasopharyngitis Porst, 2002 how much does cialis cost At least in his own mind anyway

  9. Amolymn says:

    For those that don t live close to a beach, travel is on the agenda cialis generic buy I am 59, and I do not remember being that hard in years, even back in the day when I was a young buck and ready for action any time of the day

  10. gauptex says:

    Aw boo Princess, How long have you been ttc for. nolvadex tamoxifen for sale uk i cannot recommend him highly enough.

  11. sheelty says:

    In mild cases, it consists of patches of slightly bumpy, red, or irritated looking skin, often with mild flaking and tightness of the skin around the mouth, chin, and nose. doxycycline hyclate for tooth infection

  12. poker free slots free slots 100 pay slots free video poker slots atari vegas world free slots

  13. customized paper write my paper write my paper for cheap write my papers discount code

  14. what is the best paper writing service will you write my paper for me buy academic papers paper writers college

  15. someone write my paper for me write my paper canada
    buying college papers online write my paper for money

  16. custom college paper write my paper for me fast buy college papers online paying someone to write a paper

  17. Enubank says:

    Exogenous expression of miR 15a 16 mimics re sensitized resistant cells to tamoxifen by inhibiting Cyclin E1 and B cell lymphoma 2 Bcl 2 to induce cell growth arrest and apoptosis respectively lasix renogram

  18. help writing college papers pay people to write papers write my paper for me fast https://writemypaperquick.com/

  19. pay someone to write a paper what are the best paper writing services buy papers
    online cheap paperwritinghq.com

  20. buy cheap paper online who will write my paper for me pay someone
    to write a paper for me customized writing paper

  21. help me write a paper custom writing papers help me with my paper help writing a paper for college

  22. buy dissertation paper paper writing services reviews write my economics paper i don’t want to write my paper

  23. write my english paper for me what is the best paper writing service write my papers paper writing service college

  24. odostesah says:

    ItГў s now been 42 days since Vigneault opened training camp cialis

  25. buy papers for college custom thesis papers pay to do my paper buy custom papers

  26. where to buy resume paper best online paper writing
    service pay someone to write a paper for me where to buy college papers

  27. pay someone to write a paper what is the best paper writing service buy academic
    papers paper writing website

  28. paper writing service superiorpapers write my college paper for
    me thesis paper help custom writing papers

  29. Aburela says:

    Folkman discovered, hormone fsh which in the doctor buy priligy australia

  30. Tauntee says:

    010 compared with women not exposed to an AI during their treatment for breast cancer buy nolvadex and hcg online

  31. Arreskdor says:

    Pfizer filed for EUA of the vaccine late last year, shortly before Serum Institute of India and Bharat Biotech did the same for their vaccine candidates lasix blood pressure

  32. ponseReog says:

    stromectol ebay Hill SM, Kiefer T, Teplitzky S

  33. Smeadia says:

    Adequate hemostasis was achieved via the carbon dioxide laser or Nd YAG laser; adjunct methods were required for the Er YAG laser can doxycycline cause yeast infection

  34. digedia says:

    Everest casino no deposit bonus codes. I am sincerely thankful to you for visiting website of Laar Humanitarian and Development Programme (LHDP). At least 500 g to 1 kg of samples were collected per layer in the field to determine the size distribution of ash from individual layers. Grain size analyses were conducted with manual sieving. Cone and quartered samples were dried overnight at 60C to eliminate moisture. Sieving was performed using U.S.A. Standard Test Sieves ASTM E-11-2062 in the National Institute of Geological Sciences, University of the Philippines. Lithic, crystal, and vitric components were identified and described using a stereomicroscope, counting at least 1200 grains per sample. Feedback by users According to some police reports, local incidence of reported crime often doubles or triples within three years of a casino’s opening. In a 2004 report by the US Department of Justice, researchers interviewed people who had been arrested in Las Vegas and Des Moines and found that the percentage of problem or pathological gamblers among the arrestees was three to five times higher than in the general population. https://erickyocr653108.like-blogs.com/14094186/android-roulette-using-gcash GetSlots Casino is part of Dama N.V. This is a company based in the state of Curacao. By the way, this company also manage Goodman Casino, RocketPlay, Arlekin Casino, Bitstarz and plenty of other online casinos. As for GetSlots, it is a fun and colourful online brand with great bonus offers as well as ongoing promotions. RemРµmber, if you havРµ a gР°mbling Р°ddiction plРµase visit BeGambleAware! Players can deposit and withdraw from $20 with funds landing instantly in your account when you make a deposit and released within just 12 hours when you request your withdrawal. Just make sure you have supplied the casino with your ID documents to verify your account so you don’t encounter any delays. There is a list of payment methods that you can choose from when you play at GetSlots Casino. You’ll also find each method’s transaction and deposit and withdrawal limits displayed on the page. Deposits are processed instantly at GetSlots, while withdrawals will take 12 hours.

  35. coursework only degree coursework translate coursework samples coursework based a levels

  36. coursework references coursework vs thesis masters knewton coursework coursework degree

  37. jcq coursework malpractice nea coursework history a level coursework essay coursework template

  38. coursework upm coursework uitm king’s college london coursework quantitative coursework examples

  39. sciesse says:

    三缺一是三个人等一个人,已经有三个了,一共需要四个人。 三缺一最初来自于麻将游戏中指麻将私人缺少一人而不能凑成一桌的局面,现在在网络用语中指的是因缺人而事情不能进行下去,其 首先先介绍牌张,三人麻将和四人麻将不同,他只有84张牌。分别是筒子牌,四风牌,三元牌,花牌和飞牌,如图下: 打麻将你不懂技巧?麻将大师教你5个技巧口诀 打牌不会再输_ 而且四个人,可以利用放牌给对家碰来限制下家 摸排,等等,而且三个人打节奏太快,没什么乐趣,人多也 热闹一点~ 【都业川的回答(2 票)】: 麻将几个人都是可以打的 。在我们辽宁 三缺一是三个人等一个人,已经有三个了,一共需要四个人。 三缺一最初来自于麻将游戏中指麻将私人缺少一人而不能凑成一桌的局面,现在在网络用语中指的是因缺人而事情不能进行下去,其 http://majiangxiangqi64.fotosdefrases.com/xian-shang-bai-jia-le-zhuan-qian-ptt 你的浏览器禁用了JavaScript, 请开启后刷新浏览器获得更好的体验! 最美的家常菜 2022-09-19 13:12:23   学生家长王君说:“两个孩子在同一班级,一来是作伴,二来他们可以更自信。以后既方便家长接送,辅导作业也可以更方便一些。我还给孩子做了名字牌,可以挂在脖子里,方便老师认识他们。” 最美的家常菜 2022-09-19 13:12:23 神来也麻将的游戏福利非常多,玩家也都是俊男靓女,游戏运行流畅,欢迎喜欢的朋友下载体验! 神来也麻将内置单机场,在没有网络连接时,用户则可以到单机专区打牌,游戏全天式开放,让用户真正做到自由畅玩,如在网络环境下,我们更可以提供自动匹配,开展真人竞技。

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.