MARITAL RAPE, A QUESTION OF CONSENT

Legal Aid Society, Campus Law Centre, University of Delhi

MARITAL RAPE, A QUESTION OF CONSENT

May 27, 2022 Uncategorized 190

The authors, Ms. Mahika Pant and Ms. Trisha Gupta, are final year students of LL.B. at Campus Law Centre, University of Delhi.

 

It is funny how a difference of 5 minutes before and after marriage can decide if a woman was raped or not. A split verdict given by a Division Bench of the Delhi High Court reflects two different ideas of marital rape, thus ensuring a future hearing in the Supreme Court of India.

The historical background of this issue traces back to the Bengal Phulmani case of 1889, where a 35-year-old husband raped his 11-year-old wife resulting in her death. Subsequent to this, the British government raised the age of consent from 10 years to 12 years. This move offended many sections of the society who considered it an infringement upon the institution of marriage, their customs and religion.

Our patriarchal society is obstinate about accepting the societal changes that come along with progress, evolution and empowerment, so the Government struggles to interfere with personal laws. The intricacies involved with such a move, the potential side effects for marital relationships and the flipside of wrongful accusations are all strong deterrents. This mindset is prevalent in other countries as well. Justice Hale (1736) in his History of Pleas of the Crown said that, “A husband cannot be guilty of rape committed by himself upon his lawful wife.”

It is unsettling to see that we are still governed by the colonial mindset and the same is reflected in Justice Hari Shankar’s split verdict. Firstly, he enlarges the idea of the institution of marriage over the bodily autonomy of the wife saying, “Sex between a wife and husband, whether the petitioners seek to acknowledge it or not, is sacred.” and “sex without consent is completely antithetical to the very institution of marriage”. This raises an eyebrow on the question of consent. However, on the other side of the argument, it is succinctly put by Justice Rajiv Shakdher that a sex worker has been invested with the power to say ‘no’ by the law, but not a married woman.

Marriage is an institution where two individuals come together to form a healthy, trustworthy and respectful bond. However, women have been treated as chattel right from Kanyadaan where she is gifted to her husband by the father. This flippant notion goes against the autonomy of the individual and the right of every person to make essential choices which affect the course of life, as was stated by Dr. D.Y. Chandrachud, J. in Justice K.S.Puttaswamy (Retd) v. Union of India. In a relationship where a husband and wife should be treated as equals, women are expected to be acquiescent, obeying their duties towards husbands, children, in-laws and other relatives. According to the National Family Health Survey 5 (2019-21), “Among married women aged 18-49 who have ever experienced sexual violence, 83% report their current husband and 13% report a former husband as perpetrator”.

Secondly, Justice Hari Shankar questioned whether “her experience” is the same as that of a woman who is ravaged by a stranger” and concluded that the acts of a stranger results in far greater trauma than that committed by one’s spouse. We see that it is a common assumption, that women cannot be raped by family members as we cannot fathom a daughter being raped by her father or husband. This does not negate the fact that it happens. It is a gross violation of relationships which are supposed to be based on love and sentimental ties. The institution of marriage is about more than just procreation, it is about companionship and mutual respect.

Thirdly, the judge focused on how the Indian women will be reluctant to file a complaint against their husbands. However, even if we are to consider this reasoning, the question that arises is, are we doing justice to all those other women who are willing to raise their voices against oppression? One person can inspire a whole lot and what starts out linear, becomes geometric.

Fourthly, Justice Shankar based his reasoning on the point that it is not within the court’s jurisdiction to create a new offence as it comes under the functions of the legislature. We need to understand that a new offence is not being created but merely an exception is being striked out from an existing offence which is well within the four corners of the court.

On the other hand, Justice Rajiv Shakdher’s reasoning was lauded by many wherein he upheld the bodily autonomy of women, striking down the exception as unconstitutional. Appearing on behalf of the petitioners, Advocate Karuna Nundy’s argument was supported by Justice Shakdher who concluded that the exception violated the right to life, equality, non-discrimination and freedom of speech and expression under the Constitution. The exception violates Article 14 as it creates a classification of women based on the marital status of the victims like unmarried women, live-in or divorced partners, married women and separated women. Also, such a classification has no reasonable nexus with the object of the statute to criminalise rape which is to prevent and punish non-consensual sexual intercourse. It also violates married women’s rights guaranteed under Article 21 of the Constitution.

To Counter Misuse

Every new provision added or repealed has its own implications. We cannot deny that various sections of the Indian Penal Code have been misused but this does not mean that the offence was never committed. A holistic view needs to be undertaken of the fact that women lose their identity or have it merged with that of their husbands at the time of marriage; this fact not only gives men legal authority over women but also validates the force used on her. One of the general legal principles followed around the world is that a law, if made to protect some, cannot be discredited solely on the ground that it can be misused. Justice Rajiv in the split verdict mentioned that the notion of false cases is not backed by any empirical data and that the courts are fully equipped to deal with the same.

While the criteria for determining the charges of rape should be the violation of consent, it’s true that the testimony of the victim cannot be the only evidence. The offence has to be proved beyond reasonable doubt. The data by the NCRB shows that the conviction rate for the offence of rape is fewer than 30%, keeping in mind that most of the incidents go unreported. Furthermore, the accused has a right to legal representation and present evidence that is contrary to the complainant’s claim. In the worst-case scenario of the chargesheet being filed, the accused has the right to file an application for the discharge of such a chargesheet and stop the court from framing charges. Section 482 of the CrPC can be used to quash an FIR even before trial, given that necessary evidence is provided.

The legislature can restrict the time period to lodge the FIR or ask for a preliminary investigation in the matter by taking into consideration the statements of neighbours, family and friends. The accused can also seek compensation under malicious prosecution for being falsely implicated. This in turn can be treated as a valid ground for divorce under cruelty as there is nothing more left to save in the marriage.

Conclusion

India follows a dualistic policy and it has become essential that we incorporate international laws into our municipal laws. In RIT Foundation v. Union of India and others, Senior Advocate Rebecca John, citing the Vishaka & Ors v. State of Rajasthan & Ors and Independent Thought v. Union of India judgment, stated that, “It is now a settled position of law that international conventions and laws can be read into our domestic law. India’s obligations under the Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination against Women also require and provide for Exception 2 to Section 375 to be struck down.” 

The JS Verma committee set up in the aftermath of nationwide protests over the December 16, 2012 gang rape case also recommended the same.

In a recent progressive judgement by a single-judge bench of Justice M Nagaprasanna, the Karnataka High Court said, “A man is a man; an act is an act; rape is a rape, be it performed by a man the ‘husband’ on the woman ‘wife’,” thereby refusing to quash the FIR on the ground of the said exception.

As Goethe holds, “One man’s word is no man’s word; we should quietly hear both sides.” The gruesome shadow of patriarchy has clenched our chains to the everlasting furnace of women holding the burden of societal norms, making it all the more difficult for them to raise their voice for basic fundamental rights such as dignity and bodily integrity. An appeal has been filed in the Supreme Court of India against the split verdict. We hope the judgment edifies women and honours their right to bodily autonomy by taking a leaf out of the books of other countries in criminalising marital rape.

 

(The views and opinions expressed in this article are authors’ own and do not necessarily reflect the official policy or position of the Legal Aid Society, Campus Law Centre, University of Delhi.)

190 Responses

  1. Anita says:

    I support marital rape law.

  2. You can certainly see your enthusiasm in the work you write. The sector hopes for even more passionate writers like you who aren’t afraid to mention how they believe. At all times follow your heart.

  3. smussyBub says:

    buy cialis generic Per online acquistare contrassegno devi comunicare con il farmacista online e compilare un piccolo modulo

  4. Fepclisee says:

    On the other hand, Daily Cialis can be used every day buying priligy online Three RCTs including 979 participants were identified Figure 3

  5. Tropova says:

    can you buy cialis online The individuals or entities selected as gurus may buy and sell securities before and after any particular article and report and information herein is published, with respect to the securities discussed in any article and report posted herein

  6. Ornanny says:

    clomid success rate by age 50 C 10 H 18 O 1084 l-Linalool 10 26.

  7. boufard says:

    Three studies suggest a useful effect but the cohorts are too small to draw definite conclusions 10 Further clinical research seems warranted. nolvadex

  8. Exceptional post however I was wanting to know if you could write a litte more on this topic? I’d be very grateful if you could elaborate a little bit more. Bless you!

  9. Hello.This post was extremely fascinating, particularly because I was looking for thoughts on this issue last Thursday.

  10. Guarkaree says:

    doxycycline mechanism of action If you have out of network benefits, then your insurance may reimburse you for a portion of your office visit.

  11. Voikems says:

    GH excess was observed in two patients Patients 3 and 12 lasix not working

  12. lasix 40 mg pharmacy lasix 100 mg tablet cheapest lasix 40mg

  13. luvox 50mg without prescription cheapest luvox 50 mg luvox uk

  14. Ceftin Nulp says:

    actos 30 mg online actos generic actos 30mg no prescription

  15. Inderenet says:

    Vignon F, Lippman ME, Nawata H, Derocq D, Rochefort H best cialis online Carmelo UBopUaFpZjygJ 5 20 2022

  16. calcium carbonate usa calcium carbonate 500mg tablets calcium carbonate 500 mg pharmacy

  17. macrobid 50mg price macrobid 100 mg otc how to purchase macrobid

  18. Vantin Nulp says:

    how to purchase cefuroxime cefuroxime 500mg united statescefuroxime usa how to buy cefuroxime

  19. seroquel over the counter cheap seroquel 50mg seroquel 50 mg cheap

  20. yemen says:

    Ιts like you learn my mind! You seem to understand so much approximately this, like
    you wrote the e book in it or sοmething. I think that
    you just can dο with some percent to drive the message house a little bit, Ьut insteaԀ
    of that, that is excelⅼent blog. A fantastic read.
    I’lⅼ certainly be back.

  21. Arava Nulp says:

    isosorbide without a prescription how to purchase isosorbide 40mgisosorbide uk isosorbide without a prescription

  22. Zocor Nulp says:

    prilosec online pharmacy prilosec 20 mg prices prilosec 20mg without prescription

  23. DerBrepal says:

    Data was expressed as the mean standard deviation SD of three or more independent experiments stromectol mexico Jacinto, USA 2022 06 26 20 17 38

  24. Coreg Nulp says:

    order vantin 100 mg where to buy vantin 100 mg vantin 200 mg uk

  25. Appreciate the recommendation. Will try
    it out.

  26. Very nice article, exactly what I was looking for. research dissertation

  27. where to buy propecia cost of propecia 1mg propecia 5 mg cost

  28. I really love your blog.. Great colors & theme. Did you develop this
    web site yourself? Please reply back as I’m wanting to create my own site and would like to know where you got this from or what the
    theme is named. Appreciate it!

  29. I just like the helpful info you provide in your articles.
    I’ll bookmark your blog and check once more right here frequently.
    I’m reasonably sure I will be informed plenty of new stuff proper right here!
    Good luck for the following!

  30. Aburela says:

    In this substudy of ARISTOPHANES Anticoagulants for Reduction in Stroke Observational Pooled Analysis on Health Outcomes and Experience of Patients, a large retrospective study using administrative claims data to compare outcomes among NVAF patients receiving DOACs and those receiving warfarin 6, some 40, 000 patients were identified as having active cancer prostate cancer was the most common malignancy 29, followed by breast 17, genitourinary 14, lung 13, and gastrointestinal GI 13 cancers cialis and priligy

  31. Brandonpal says:

    This is nicely said. !
    legal canadian pharmacy no perscription pharmacy buying drugs from canada legal

  32. Keithagrig says:

    Thank you! Plenty of content!
    cvs pharmacy in canada provigil canadian pharmacy canadian pharmaceutical prices

  33. buy celebrex 200mg celebrex 100 mg pills celebrex 200 mg without a prescription

  34. RenaldoProft says:

    You revealed that well!

  35. how to buy calcium carbonate 500 mg calcium carbonate 500mg online calcium carbonate cheap

  36. JamesNisse says:

    You explained that fantastically!
    true canadian pharmacy israel pharmacy online online pharmacy adderall

  37. ThomasMob says:

    Appreciate it. Numerous stuff.
    best india pharmacy price medication new drugs for ed

  38. pulmicort cost pulmicort 100mcg otc pulmicort 100 mcg canada

  39. Keithagrig says:

    Seriously tons of superb info!
    family pharmacy apply to cvs pharmacy online cheap canadian pharmacy

  40. ThomasMob says:

    Great information. Thanks a lot!
    24 hour online pharmacy international pharmacy no prescription canadian pharmacies that deliver to the us

  41. Keithagrig says:

    Excellent advice. Cheers.
    free live pharmacy tech ce online what are the best online canadian pharmacies ED Trial Pack

  42. Antoniophalk says:

    You explained this fantastically.
    canadian pharmacies comparison hannaford pharmacy 1 canadian pharmacy

  43. Arreskdor says:

    Aitkenhead M metolazone before lasix Using Tamoxifen for long periods of time can increase the risk of uterine cancer in women if they haven t undergone a hysterectomy

  44. WilfordWergo says:

    Nicely put, Many thanks!
    canadiandrugstore com costco pharmacy online refill pharmacy technician degrees online

  45. Antoniophalk says:

    Kudos! Useful information!
    va pharmacy online pharmacy usa canada pharmacy com

  46. Tauntee says:

    PMID 31178825 Free PMC article tamoxifen citrate 20mg We have previously examined the role of hyperactivation of ERK1 2 MAPK hMAPK occurring downstream of EGFR or HER2 in breast cancer

  47. RichardKef says:

    Seriously tons of useful data!
    va pharmacy british pharmacy online reviews of canadian online pharmacies

  48. Stanleyanect says:

    You actually suggested this exceptionally well!
    pharmacy online school best canadian pharmacies for cialis 24 store pharmacy

  49. Keithagrig says:

    Seriously loads of great material!
    sky pharmacy online canadian neighbor pharmacy reviews top rated online pharmacy

  50. motrin price says:

    cephalexin 500mg uk https://cephalexine.com/# – cephalexin 500mg uk cephalexin 500mg uk

  51. Stanleyanect says:

    You actually revealed this fantastically.
    canada pet pharmacy no prescription cheap drugs from canada albany college of pharmacy

  52. DavidGauth says:

    Cheers, A lot of data!
    singulair canadian pharmacy top 10 online pharmacies online pharmacy without prescription

  53. Keithagrig says:

    You explained it very well!
    cvs pharmacy store locator prescription drugs facts prescription drugs

  54. DavidGauth says:

    Superb facts. Cheers.
    online pharmacy australia walgreens pharmacy online refill voltaren gel canada pharmacy

  55. Keithagrig says:

    Cheers, A good amount of content.
    aarp canadian pharmacy discount pharmaceuticals alliance rx pharmacy

  56. Keithagrig says:

    Superb postings, Thanks a lot!
    high street discount pharmacy pharmacy canada international pharmacies

  57. MichaelOccax says:

    Wonderful information, With thanks.
    canadian pharmacy us legitimate mexican pharmacy online reliable canadian pharmacies

  58. Keithagrig says:

    You have made the point!
    tricare pharmacy online canada discount drugs online percocet canadian pharmacy

  59. empippido says:

    clomid men The actor used Twitter to show off this super buff snapshot of himself getting into character on the set of his upcoming movie and to give his personal trainer Jon Paul Crimi a special shout out

  60. Richardtib says:

    Wonderful material. Thank you.
    certified canadian pharmacy online how to get drugs from canada canadian pharmacy cialis 10mg

  61. MichaelOccax says:

    Thank you, Numerous stuff.
    shoppers drug mart canada canadian compounding pharmacy order prescription drugs online without doctor

  62. Keithagrig says:

    You said this adequately!
    canada pharmacy on line reviews recreditable canadian pharmacies canada prescriptions online

  63. Richardtib says:

    Amazing a good deal of good tips.
    cheapest pharmacy trusted online canadian pharmacy reviews online pharmacy europe

  64. Lesterawaix says:

    Many thanks. Very good stuff!
    canadian drugs northwest pharmacy mutual of omaha rx pharmacy directory canadian pharmacy com

  65. Keithagrig says:

    You said it perfectly..
    does medicare cover prescription drugs no prescription drugs canada legal online pharmacies

  66. WilliamWet says:

    Fantastic advice. Thanks a lot.
    canada pharmacy 24h accurate rx pharmacy columbia mo mexico pharmacy online

  67. Lesterawaix says:

    With thanks! Fantastic stuff.
    online drugstore service canada canadian online pharmacy surrey bc canadian pharcharmy online

  68. Keithagrig says:

    Good info, Appreciate it!
    online pharmacy no presc uk best ed medication buy prescription drugs in canada

  69. WilliamWet says:

    You made your position extremely well..
    okay google canadian pharmacies on the web best rated canadian online pharmacies drugs from canada reviews

  70. ponseReog says:

    The photo brings to mind a poem by the fourteenth century mystic poet Cecil, USA 2022 06 18 05 35 32 acheter stromectol en ligne I have 60 10mg nolvadex, one bottle of retain2, and one bottle of ATD 90 25mg caps

  71. Scottwheem says:

    Nicely put. With thanks.
    canadian prescription drugs global pharmacy canada problems canadian pharmacy compare

  72. Keithagrig says:

    Perfectly voiced truly! !
    canadian online pharmacy no prescription cvs pharmacy in store coupons pharmacy on line

  73. Williamgrova says:

    You actually stated that really well!
    rx pharmacy online 24 canada pharmacy estrogen without prescription canadian pharmacy generic levitra

  74. Scottwheem says:

    Valuable write ups. Many thanks!
    best erectile dysfunction pills canadian pharmacy lantus best online non prescription pharmacy

  75. Keithagrig says:

    Valuable information. Many thanks!
    abc pharmacy online [url=https://sopharmsn.com/]pharmacy tech online courses[/url] canada drugs winnipeg mb canada

  76. Williamgrova says:

    Awesome stuff. Thank you.
    how to dispose of prescription drugs canadian mail order pharmacy reviews french pharmacy online

  77. Josephengiz says:

    Cheers, I enjoy it.
    canadian 24 pharmacy pharmacy times best drugstore eye cream

  78. Thomasbeity says:

    Cheers! Good stuff.
    rx on line pharmacy wal mart store pharmacy vicodin canadian pharmacy

  79. PeterCaw says:

    You said it very well.!
    reliable canadian pharmacy online pharmacy no presc uk pharmacy technician degree online

  80. Josephengiz says:

    You made your point pretty nicely!.
    prescription drugs that get you high canadian pharmacy online no prescription needed canadian pharmacy naples fl

  81. Thomasbeity says:

    Thanks! I enjoy it!
    cross border pharmacy canada canadian pharmacy advair subutex online pharmacy

  82. Smeadia says:

    does doxycycline However, in some studies there was a noted drop of Free Testosterone, despite the increase in Total Testosterone R, R

  83. PeterCaw says:

    Reliable stuff. Appreciate it.
    pharmacy websites prescription drugs online canadian pharmacy meds review

  84. RenaldoProft says:

    You actually mentioned this really well!
    health canada recall drugs pharmacy schools online southern pharmacy

  85. Keithagrig says:

    Thanks a lot! Valuable information.
    wholesale pharmacy online botox canada pharmacy pharmacy montreal canada

  86. Richardtet says:

    Wow plenty of helpful advice!
    canadian pharmacies for dogs trusted canadian pharmacy canadian pharmacy hydrocodone

  87. RenaldoProft says:

    Appreciate it, Lots of write ups!
    do canadian pharmacies sell generic viagra best canadian drugstore eu online pharmacy

  88. Keithagrig says:

    You definitely made your point!
    king soopers pharmacy online course for pharmacy technician best online non prescription pharmacy

  89. coumadin without a doctor prescription coumadin coupon coumadin 2mg cost

  90. Richardtet says:

    You actually mentioned it perfectly.
    store hours for walgreens pharmacy prescription drugs from india best drugstore face moisturizer

  91. Justinbaimb says:

    Incredible loads of very good facts!
    pharmacy shoe store canadian pharmacy shop coupon code pharmacy shop online

  92. Keithagrig says:

    With thanks, Quite a lot of info!
    canadian pharmacies in canada can you buy prescription drugs online legally mens ed pills

  93. Robertassor says:

    Nicely put, Thanks.
    best canadian online pharmacies legal drugs in canada best online pharmacy for generic cialis

  94. Justinbaimb says:

    You stated that fantastically!
    ordering prescription drugs from canada canadian pharmacy tylenol with codeine mail order prescription drugs

  95. Keithagrig says:

    Very good material. Thank you.
    pharmacy websites online pharmacy pain relief trustworthy canadian online pharmacy

  96. Robertassor says:

    Superb content. With thanks.
    dominican republic pharmacy online walgreens pharmacy refill online prescription drug costs

  97. DouglasToige says:

    You definitely made your point!
    hot canadian pharmacy prescription drugs finder pharmacy tech schooling online

  98. Keithagrig says:

    Kudos, Plenty of stuff.
    reliable rx pharmacy coupons onlinepharmaciescanada com azithromycin canada pharmacy

  99. Davidmalag says:

    Great material. Appreciate it.
    canadian government approved pharmacies help rx pharmacy discount card canadian pharmacy adderall xr

  100. Looking at this article, I miss the time when I didn’t wear a mask. bitcoincasino Hopefully this corona will end soon. My blog is a blog that mainly posts pictures of daily life before Corona and landscapes at that time. If you want to remember that time again, please visit us.

  101. DouglasToige says:

    Seriously many of superb facts!
    unc student store pharmacy canadianpharmacyworld com walmart pharmacy viagra

  102. Keithagrig says:

    Many thanks! Loads of write ups.
    trustworthy canadian pharmacies buy veterinary drugs online canada canadian pharmacy generic viagra

  103. Davidmalag says:

    Lovely write ups. Thanks a lot.
    prescription drugs canadian colleges of clinical pharmacy canadian pharmacy viagra 200mg

  104. Nice weblog here! Also your web site lots up very fast! What web host are you the usage of? Can I get your affiliate link to your host? I wish my site loaded up as fast as yours lol

  105. Billyicene says:

    Incredible plenty of wonderful tips.
    medicine store pharmacy springfield, mo erectile dysfunction canadian pharmacy online store
    online walmart pharmacy southern pharmacy walgreens pharmacy store locations
    https://canadadrugspower.com/ thesis defence

  106. Keithagrig says:

    Useful data. Regards!
    rx pharmacy meaning rx pharmacy canadian pharmacy cialis 5mg

  107. Josephwal says:

    With thanks. I value this!
    propecia online pharmacy online pharmacy viagra canadian pharmacy for sildenafil
    prescription price checker pharmacy technician training program online cheap prescription drugs online
    https://canadianonlinepharmacybase.com/ write my admission essay

  108. Billyicene says:

    You actually explained it effectively.
    top online canadian pharmacies top online canadian pharmacies canadian drug store coupon
    pharmacy drug store online no rx viagra online canadian pharmacy reviews online pharmacy no presc
    https://canadadrugspower.com/ buy pre written essays

  109. Josephwal says:

    Cheers. Very good stuff.
    best ed pills pharmacy technician online certification lunesta canadian pharmacy
    cheapest pharmacy for prescriptions without insurance best mail order canadian pharmacy Viagra Super Active
    https://canadianonlinepharmacybase.com/ personal essay writing prompts

  110. Brandonpal says:

    Fantastic content, Regards!
    women’s international pharmacy global pharmacy canada complaints canadian pharmacy milwaukee

  111. Jamalfot says:

    Whoa quite a lot of useful information.
    finasteride online pharmacy no perscription drugs canada erectile dysfunction medications
    canadian pharmacies cipro hc suspension 0.2-1% canada drugs finasteride online pharmacy
    https://canadapharmacies-24h.com/ dissertation papers

  112. Jamessuift says:

    Fantastic write ups. Regards!
    pharmacy online india vipps canadian online pharmacy pharmacy technician certification
    online order medicine prescription drugs diarrhea best canada pharmacy
    https://canadianpharmacyonlinedb.com/ writing services

  113. Brandonpal says:

    You actually reported it perfectly!
    buy prescription drugs canada mexico online pharmacy reviews precision rx specialty pharmacy

  114. Jamalfot says:

    Cheers! A good amount of stuff.
    letrozole online pharmacy online canadian pharmacy cialis best prescription prices
    canadian pharmacy king complaints canadian no prescription pharmacy canada drugs cialis
    https://canadapharmacies-24h.com/ do your homework for you

  115. Jamessuift says:

    Terrific stuff. Thanks!
    best online pharmacy cialis what happened to canadian pharmacies best drugstore makeup
    compounding pharmacy canada canadian pharmacy phentermine pharmacy tech online programs
    https://canadianpharmacyonlinedb.com/ help in writing essays

  116. Clauderex says:

    You actually mentioned it effectively!
    prescription drugs online canadian pharmacy locations buy ed medication
    canada pet pharmacy uriel pharmacy online store canadian drugs without any prescriptions
    https://canadianpharmaceuticalsonlineus.com/ do your homework for you

  117. Aaronlah says:

    Amazing lots of terrific data.
    canadian pharmacies for dogs prescription cost canadian pharmacy king reviews

  118. Edwardjex says:

    This is nicely put! .
    canadian healthcare online pharmacy reviews canadian family pharmacy reviews accredited online pharmacy technician programs
    24 hour pharmacy pharmacy tech rite aid pharmacy
    https://northwestpharmacylabs.com/ umi publishing

  119. Clauderex says:

    Regards! Valuable information.
    no perscription pharmacy pharmacy technician salary canada costco pharmacy online refill
    canadian pharmacies no prescription walmart pharmacy refill online canadian pharmacies online legitimate
    https://canadianpharmaceuticalsonlineus.com/ professional writing company

  120. Aaronlah says:

    Great info. Cheers.
    pharmacy technician letter metcare rx pharmacy vipps certified canadian pharmacy

  121. Edwardjex says:

    Thanks. I enjoy this!
    cheapest pharmacy for prescription drugs us based online pharmacy pharmacy tech study guide online
    canadian pharmacies list dilaudid online pharmacy best online mexican pharmacy
    https://northwestpharmacylabs.com/ tourism thesis

  122. DonaldSip says:

    Many thanks, Lots of content.
    dog pharmacy online online medicine tablets shopping 24 hr pharmacy
    walmart neighborhood store pharmacy canadian pharmacy naples fl best canadian pharmacies reviews
    https://canadianpharmacies-24h.com/ dissertation scholarships

  123. Richardfenda says:

    Great forum posts. Many thanks!
    canada pharmacy coupon flying with prescription drugs in checked luggage list of trusted canadian pharmacies
    canadian pharmacy compare canadian pharmacy discount coupon drugstore makeup
    https://onlinepharmacycanadahelp.com/ how to write an apa paper

  124. ClaudeGax says:

    You suggested it effectively.
    levitra canada pharmacy canadian pharmacy lakeland fl pharmacy rx solutions

  125. DonaldSip says:

    Thank you! Very good stuff.
    pharmacy tech practice tests online free new ed drugs canadian king pharmacy
    synthroid canadian pharmacy humana rx pharmacy india rx pharmacy
    https://canadianpharmacies-24h.com/ custom paper service

  126. Richardfenda says:

    Regards. Lots of content.
    prescription drugs information rite aid pharmacy store locator consumer reports canadian pharmacies
    pharmacy school canadian pharmacy delivery what canadian pharmacies are legitimate
    https://onlinepharmacycanadahelp.com/ models for writers short essays for composition

  127. ClaudeGax says:

    Thanks a lot, Great information!
    prescription drugs to speed up metabolism abusable prescription drugs pharmacy canadian

  128. BrandonNoult says:

    You made the point!
    no prior prescription required pharmacy canada drugs without perscription why are drugs cheaper in canada
    enbrel canadian pharmacy american pharmacy store shoppers drug mart canada
    https://usapharmsn.com/ best cheap essay writing service

  129. Earnestgog says:

    Kudos. I appreciate this.
    online pharmacies that use paypal discount drugs medicine store pharmacy springfield, mo
    online prescriptions canada without live pharmacy ce online canadian pharmacy northwest
    https://sopharmsn.com/ writing a grad school essay

  130. BrandonNoult says:

    You said this fantastically.
    how to get drugs from canada malaysia pharmacy store online pharmacy review
    online pharmacy computers prescription drug prices comparison rx pharmacy logo
    https://usapharmsn.com/ university of texas homework

  131. Earnestgog says:

    Thanks. Quite a lot of postings.
    overseas pharmacy best drugstore eyeshadow canada drugs
    best pharmacy schools canada pharmacies online pill pharmacy
    https://sopharmsn.com/ how to write an introduction to an essay

  132. Michaelthalp says:

    Kudos. I appreciate this!
    discount drug store online shopping capsule online pharmacy online pharmacy pain relief

  133. Michaelthalp says:

    Valuable tips. Appreciate it.
    no perscription pharmacy your rx pharmacy 1st rx pharmacy statesville nc

  134. TimothyMow says:

    Whoa all kinds of good tips!
    informed rx pharmacy help desk canadian pharmacy testosterone canadian pharmacy spam
    canadian pharmacies without an rx canadian prescriptions online prescription drugs account for 25 of all healthcare related costs
    https://uspharmacymsn.com/ boston college essays

  135. VincentTex says:

    You actually suggested this really well.
    prescription without a doctor’s prescription voltaren gel canadian pharmacy canadian drug pharmacy
    listing of prescription drugs order prescriptions certified canadian pharmacy
    https://spharmacymsn.com/ help me write a research paper

  136. TimothyMow says:

    Kudos. Lots of data.
    pharmacy open near me help rx pharmacy discount card pharmacy technician requirements in canada
    alpesh pharmacy store charlotte nc epiduo canadian pharmacy cvs pharmacy inside target store
    https://uspharmacymsn.com/ how to write cool letters on paper

  137. Rogerlople says:

    You said it nicely.!
    become a pharmacy technician online international pharmacies that ship to the usa live pharmacy ce online

  138. Rogerlople says:

    You made the point!
    online medicine to buy cvs pharmacy store near me canadian pharmacy service

  139. JamesNuP says:

    Incredible plenty of fantastic facts.
    fda approved online pharmacy one rx pharmacy prescription costs

  140. JamesNuP says:

    Nicely put, With thanks!
    cheap drugs online pharmacy reviews forum australian online pharmacy

  141. ErnestNip says:

    Truly plenty of good data!
    street names for prescription drugs best canadian online pharmacy reviews is canadian pharmacy world legit

  142. ErnestNip says:

    Factor very well used!!
    sildenafil citrate online pharmacy one rx pharmacy amoxicillin canadian pharmacy

  143. Charlesreito says:

    Thank you. Fantastic information!
    safe canadian pharmacies to order from is canadian pharmacy real meijer pharmacy store hours

  144. Charlesreito says:

    You expressed this fantastically!
    lasix online pharmacy legitimate canadian pharmacy online reliable canadian pharmacy discount code

  145. Thomasbeity says:

    You actually reported it really well.
    costco pharmacy online canada drugs lp canadian international pharmacy

  146. Thomasbeity says:

    You definitely made your point!
    the drug store pharmacy care rx pharmacy tallahassee fl prescription drugs that get you high

  147. JosephInedO says:

    Superb content, Regards.
    rx outreach pharmacy pharmacy school online online pharmacy meds

  148. tricor australia tricor 160 mg for sale tricor 200mg pills

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.