DEATH PENALTY SATISFYING SOCIETY’S CRY FOR JUSTICE: A CRITIQUE

Legal Aid Society, Campus Law Centre, University of Delhi

DEATH PENALTY SATISFYING SOCIETY’S CRY FOR JUSTICE: A CRITIQUE

July 17, 2022 Uncategorized 69

The author, Sagar Soni, is a Contributing Editor at Awaaz and a final year student of LL.B. at Campus Law Centre, Faculty of Law, University of Delhi.

Introduction

On 9 May 1980, the Constitution Bench of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India delivered a historic judgment on the issue of ‘Death Penalty in India’ in the case of Bachan Singh v. State Of Punjab whereby the Hon’ble Court provided the doctrine of ‘Rarest of Rare’ cases. Their Lordships in Bachan Singh case categorically stated that judges shouldn’t be the spokesmen of public opinion. However, a major shift was seen in the judicial approach when despite a clear indication by the Constitution Bench, the Courts started addressing ‘society’s cry for justice’ or ‘shock to the collective conscience of society’ as a relevant factor while awarding death penalty.

Discarding Bachan Singh

Post Bachan Singh, the factor of ‘society’s cry for justice’ was first considered in the case of Machhi Singh and Ors. v. State of Punjab (1983) wherein the Hon’ble Apex Court basically opined that, if the collective conscience of society is so shocked by the crime that it would expect the judiciary to impose a death sentence, then it may be considered as a factor for determining the capital punishment. Further, in the case of Machhi Singh and Sushil Murmu v. State of Jharkhand (2003), the Apex Court even observed that ‘Irrespective of the personal opinion of holder of judicial power’, the death penalty can be awarded if the shocked collective conscience of society demands so. So, it can be clearly understood that in certain cases, the society’s opinion which on various occasion is mostly backed by emotions and sentiments have been considered to have more weightage than a reasoned judicial opinion. The same observation, in one or another way, was followed in a plethora of cases ranging from trial courts to the apex court whereby such factors were considered. In a study of ‘Death Penalty Sentencing in Trial Courts’ (Published in 2020) conducted by ‘Project 39A’, it was found that in 112 of 215 cases of awarding capital punishment by trial courts in Delhi, Madhya Pradesh and Maharashtra, the factor of ‘Collective Conscience’/‘Society’s cry for justice’ was invoked. It was further observed that in 63 of those 112 cases, almost no mitigating factor was considered. Therefore, it is clearly visible that courts in India are rampantly adopting an approach that Bachan Singh explicitly discarded.

Conflicting opinions

Although, the judiciary has been invoking the factor of society’s cry for justice on various occasions as explained above, but still there is a great conflict of opinion among holders of judicial powers, inside and outside the court. Starting from Machhi Singh, the consideration of society’s cry for justice in the case of Dhananjoy Chaterjee v. State of West Bengal (1994) to placing reliance on it in Mukesh & Anr v. State for NCT of Delhi (2017) and even after that; shows that there exists a great block of judicial scholarship in favour of considering aforementioned factors while awarding capital punishment. However, on the other hand, there are many pertinent judicial observations that discard consideration of such factors in death penalty cases. In ­­­Santosh Kumar Satishbhushan Bariyar v. State of Maharashtra (2009) (one of the significant judgments in this context), a division bench of the Hon’ble Apex Court observed that, considering public opinion is not compatible with the Bachan Singh doctrine as the duty of the judiciary as per the constitution is to take a perspective on individual rights at a higher pedestal than majoritarian aspirations. Thereafter, in the case of M.A. Antony @ Antappan v. State Of Kerala (2018), Justice M. B. Lokur, speaking for a three-judge bench, observed that it would be wise if the impression gathered on public opinion are avoided while sentencing. Further, in Shankar Kisanrao Khade v. State of Maharashtra (2013), the Hon’ble Apex Court also doubted the confirmation of capital punishment in Dhananjoy Chaterjee (Supra) which considered the factor of society’s cry for justice as relevant. Even the Law Commission of India in its Report on Death Penalty (2015) noted that “a cohesive, coherent and consistent “public opinion” is a fiction”. So, there are various instances where such factors have been considered to be irrelevant.

Further, in a report titled “Matters of Judgment”, the Project 39A reported that in interviews with some of the Supreme Court judges, there were 11 Hon’ble judges who considered the inclusion of Collective Conscience as a relevant factor,and on the other hand, there were 15 Hon’ble judges who discarded the same. The former argued that a crime can only be judged with respect to the effect on the public as to how the public feels about it, and what the public thinks about it. But, the latter rejecting any legitimacy for collective conscience stated that it reflects the ‘Mob Justice’. Hence it can be clearly observed that judicial scholarship is divided on this issue so it becomes necessary to examine the issues related to considering such factors as relevant.

Issues in considering society’s cry for justice:

In general, the society would be shocked by every crime and the supporters of the retributive theory of punishment would definitely demand an eye for an eye. Although, the nature of crime is also a relevant factor in determining the collective conscience of society, but every act of murder or rape, etc. is indeed considered as brutal in the society. So, the first and foremost problem with this factor is to define precisely what public opinion is and to determine as to when the collective conscience of society is so shocked. As observed in Bariyar case, if such a factor is considered, then the possibility of media trial cannot be ruled out. Hence, there can also be circumstances when the cry for justice would be selective. For example, there was a huge uproar by the common public after the 2012 Delhi gang-rape and murder case popularly known as the ‘Nirbhaya case’. However, it cannot be outlined that there was no such other rape and murder case post Nirbhaya case when 77 cases of rape are reported daily in India; but the outrage or society’s cry for justice was never the same as it was in Nirbhaya case. Hence, sometimes the public opinion is also based on what is informed to them; which makes this factor less reliable and also prejudicial to the accused as observed in the cases reported in the study by Project 39A (supra) where no mitigating circumstances were considered. Such an attempt is also prejudicial because by not taking the mitigating factors into account, the courts are particularly discarding the ratio laid down in the Bachan Singh case which mandated to weigh the crime committed by the accused and his mitigating circumstance. In Bariyar case, it was also observed that judges do not engage in much discussion on aggravating or mitigating circumstances. In this way, the judiciary somehow seems to be inclined toward a majoritarian approach whereby judges are taking up a responsibility on themselves to satisfy the majoritarian call for retribution. It must be understood that judges are not the chosen or elected representatives of the people, but are governed by constitutional safeguards. Hence, it is not their duty to work as per the wishes of the public, but to consider every situation with fairness, reasonableness, and equal treatment. The public opinion MAY BE devoid of reasoning on the circumstances of crime or criminal, hence, placing reliance on such opinion would be detrimental to the criminal justice system.  Further, one of the important penological goals of a penalty under a criminal justice system is deterrence. However, the studies have suggested that there is no informative research to suggest that capital punishment has any deterrence effect on homicide rates.[1] Further, it has been also observed that there is little evidence to show that severity in punishment has a material deterrence effect, in fact it is the certainty of punishment which have been found to have more deterrent effect in crimes.[2] The Law Commission of India, in its Death Penalty Report (supra), has also observed that death penalty doesn’t serve the objective of deterrence any more than that of life imprisonment, and it further concluded that focusing on capital punishment also affects the restorative and rehabilitative aspects of justice. Hence, it can be averred from the discussion above that taking the majoritarian call for retribution into consideration may still have no impact on deterrence, but it will surely take away the possibility of reformation of a person so sentenced.

Conclusion

At present time, Abolitionistic trends are going on in the world with respect to death penalty. Various countries are discarding the death penalty as a form of punishment but the legitimacy or abolition of the death penalty in India is a matter of another discussion. However, it must be considered that when the world is trying to abolish capital punishment, we should at least try to discourage such punishment especially when it is called for satisfying the majoritarian view of the society. The pertinent issues as stated above implies that relying on public opinion, and thereby discarding the possibility of reformation by not considering mitigating circumstance is against the basic principles of the Indian Criminal Justice system regarding the duty of judges as observed in Bachan Singh. In case, the legislature or the judiciary still finds it difficult to discourage the death penalty, it would be advisable to follow the precedent of the constitutional bench as courts are bound by the precedents and not by a response of the society which could be incoherent. Hence, the clear warning stated in Bachan Singh as the judges shouldn’t be the spokesperson of the public deserves due consideration in order to meet the ends of justice.

[1] National Research Council, Deterrence and the Death Penalty (Washington DC: The National Academic Press, 2012)

[2] Daniel S. Nagin, “Deterrence in the Twenty-First Century” Vol. 42, No. 1, Crime and Justice in America 1975-2025 199 (August 2013).

(The views and opinions expressed in this article are author’s own and do not necessarily reflect the official policy or position of the Legal Aid Society, Campus Law Centre, University of Delhi.)

 

 

 

 

 

 

69 Responses

  1. Ajit Nandan says:

    Interesting, insightful, in-depth, & enlightening piece for reading. A must read. Well done Sagar.

  2. Pooja Dongre says:

    Well explained Sagar ji . You make it to understand easily .

  3. Usha Rani says:

    Sagar my son you have Good knowledge about this topic. Weldon.continue with your super mind

  4. Hi my friend! I want to say that this post is amazing, great written and include approximately all vital infos. I would like to see extra posts like this.

  5. Hey! I know this is kinda off topic but I was wondering if you knew where I could find a captcha plugin for my comment form? I’m using the same blog platform as yours and I’m having problems finding one? Thanks a lot!

  6. Edgetly says:

    cialis online without prescription Potential For Other Drugs To Affect CIALIS

  7. Incerreda says:

    Viagra e Cialis ha delle somiglianze e delle differenze priligy review youtube

  8. Spouttoca says:

    where to buy cialis cheap We just need to do our own thing, and we do not need to worry about the rest

  9. Uploash says:

    where can i buy cialis on line Food has no effect on tadalafil the active substance in Cialis Super Active

  10. suikino says:

    tamoxifen package insert We ve written them to ask about extending their reach to Canada and will update when we hear anything.

  11. I together with my guys ended up following the great thoughts on your web site while instantly I had a horrible suspicion I had not expressed respect to the web blog owner for them. My women are already absolutely very interested to read all of them and have now pretty much been loving those things. Thank you for really being really considerate as well as for finding some helpful useful guides millions of individuals are really desperate to know about. Our sincere regret for not expressing gratitude to earlier.

  12. Hello.This article was really motivating, particularly because I was searching for thoughts on this matter last Wednesday.

  13. I consider something truly special in this web site.

  14. Hi there! Do you know if they make any plugins to assist with Search Engine Optimization? I’m trying to get my blog to rank for some targeted keywords but I’m not seeing very good gains. If you know of any please share. Appreciate it!

  15. Drerhoome says:

    doxycycline hyclate online ZYRTEC- D cetirizine, pseudoephedrine Tablets may be given with or without food see DOSAGE AND ADMINISTRATION.

  16. paper writing service reviews professional paper writing service college
    papers to buy best paper writers

  17. help with college paper writing custom writing papers buy
    a college paper pay for someone to write your paper

  18. Pdf Editor says:

    Looking for an online pdf editor that is both easy to use and powerful? Look no further than A1office! With our online pdf editor, you can quickly and easily make changes to your pdf documents. Whether you need to add text, images, or signatures, our pdf editor has you covered. Plus, our software is 100% free to use!

  19. college papers writing service custom papers review buying papers best paper writing service

  20. someone to write my paper for me writing services for
    college papers can someone write my paper online paper writing services

  21. artevow says:

    For the CBS enzyme, the reaction mixture contains the same as for the CSE plus 1 mM homocysteine lasix for water retention

  22. buy a college paper custom thesis papers custom written college papers custom writing papers

  23. custom written paper write my custom paper instant paper writer https://studentpaperhelp.com/

  24. apa papers for sale find someone to write
    my college paper find someone to write my college paper write my paper cheap

  25. cheap custom papers best college paper writing
    service custom note paper college papers for sale

  26. write my paper for money write my paper cheap customized writing paper paying someone to write a paper

  27. paper writers college write my business paper pay someone to do my paper paper writers college

  28. help with writing papers do my paper for money custom paper writers college paper writers

  29. Femfleera says:

    Colin EZEfSwWcsleOVxuyJtl 5 20 2022 cheapest cialis available 5 or the ER, HER2 phenotype 4

  30. best online paper writing service paper writing company custom
    thesis papers pay someone to write a paper

  31. what are the best paper writing services help in writing paper pay someone to write my paper i need someone to write my paper

  32. need help writing my paper help write my paper help me
    write my paper write my paper for me cheap

  33. will someone write my paper for me custom written papers online
    paper writer write my paper apa style

  34. write my paper in apa format find someone to write my paper buy college papers
    online custom papers online

  35. find someone to write my paper buy papers online
    cheap find someone to write my college paper paper writers for college

  36. DerBrepal says:

    Immunity 41 843 852 29 purchase ivermectin 3mg Sample Bulking Stack Sample Cutting Stack RAD 140 20mg day RAD 140 20mg day Ligandrol 10mg day Cardarine 10mg day YK11 10mg day Andarine 50mg day Sample RAD 140 Bulking Cutting Stacks

  37. apparalob says:

    org which supports high school students to perform biomedical research in laboratories throughout the country buy ivermectin for scabies For this reason, those with unprovoked VTE usually receive longer treatment than patients with provoked VTE

  38. Tauntee says:

    Substanz Nandrolone decanoate Deca Paket 10ml Fläschchen 600mg ml Hersteller Pharmacom Labs nolvadex on sale usa

  39. ponseReog says:

    Tumor Morphology ivermectin 3mg tab How long should this NPP Nolva cocktail mess with me

  40. empippido says:

    where can i get fertomid The growth of OR negative DCIS is driven by activation of the type 1 tyrosine kinase cell surface receptors epidermal growth factor receptor EGFR and HER 2 receptor and can be inhibited by EGFR receptor antagonists Chan et al, 2002

  41. majorsite says:

    As I am looking at your writing, majorsite I regret being unable to do outdoor activities due to Corona 19, and I miss my old daily life. If you also miss the daily life of those days, would you please visit my site once? My site is a site where I post about photos and daily life when I was free.

  42. Arreskdor says:

    lasix for pneumonia Another arm of the study evaluates synergistic effects between CoQ10 and other chemotherapeutic agents

  43. coursework topics cpa coursework coursework in or on coursework-expert.com

  44. coursework vs research masters coursework vs thesis
    masters nea coursework history a level coursework example

  45. This web site is really a walk-through for all of the info you wanted about this and didn’t know who to ask. Glimpse here, and you’ll definitely discover it.

  46. Very informative and good structure of subject matter, now that’s user friendly (:.

  47. coursework history custom coursework writing service coursework for psychology degree coursework spelling

  48. digedia says:

    The best slots machine game available from the palm of your hand! Mr Green is well-respected among online casino operators and is known as the gentleman of online casino operators. Mr Green has a large variety of games you can play and things you can bet on. From number games to slots, table games, and sportsbook, we have plenty to keep you entertained in a safe and fair environment. Our number one priority at Mr Green is that we offer responsible gaming to our clients. With our innovative Predictive Tool, we are setting new standards in the industry for allowing players to control and monitor their gambling behavior. Ultimately, it’s the priority and importance that Mr Green puts on our customers that enables you to have the best gaming experience possible. The Multiply by two tombol di window permainan akan menerangi untuk memberikan nasihat kepada Guitar player yang tersedia pilihan ini. This is especially useful when you are the type of Indian player that enjoys playing an online slot machine. The trusted live casino MaIaysia offers a wide variety of games that are easily accessibIe and can be played anywhere across the globe. Kajot – Kajot is popular amongst Czech and Slovak individuals usually, thanks to the availability of Kajot spots present in Czech and Slovak acreage based casinos. Rapid bursts of cellular casino gameplay are also fewer very likely to create fatigue, which usually leads to errors. https://futafantasy.net/community/profile/prestonpoore06/ Basically, free spins are a type of online casino bonus that allow you to play slots games without spending any of your own money. There are different types of free spins bonuses, plus lots of other info on free spins, which you can read all about on this page. All of our games are easy to enjoy and you can find full instructions on how to play each one right here on the Spin247 website. Most have at least one mini-game feature where you can win extra multipliers, and many have a Gamble or Free Spins mode that can help to increase your prizes. Perhaps most exciting of all, you can also play for our fast-growing progressive Jackpots every time you spin. That said, some of our best mobile casinos like Intertops and Americas Cardroom have gone the extra mile to create mobile casino apps for players. This means instant access to online casinos without needing to go through the browser.

  49. king’s college london coursework coursework program coursework guidelines coursework vs exams

  50. coursework requirements narrative coursework examples
    coursework thesis coursework in korean

  51. coursework for business administration coursework thesis coursework gcse coursework handbook

  52. sciesse says:

    道阻且长,行则将至;行而不辍,未来可期。前方的路会有曲折,但也充满希望。中国共产党愿继续同各国政党和政治组织一道,站在历史正确的一边,站在人类进步的一边,为推动构建人类命运共同体、建设更加美好的世界作出新的更大贡献! 邹华称,“老西麻将”上线一年,每天的活跃玩家约15万人,每个月用户充值的金额已超过一千万元。3000多名代理中,一般月入三五千,也有过万的,为了规避风险,代理的返利也都通过微信公众号进行,不会在平台上提现。 ug。3.1.4同时也包括了其它的几个安全修复和安全加固措施。可以点击更新日志查看更新的内容。下载WordPress3.1.4或者在控制面板里面的更新获得版本。WordPress 3.2.1在 Wor https://donovanjcsh219864.theisblog.com/14431041/神-來-也-網站 wepoker微扑克下载 发牌的话一般来说是最后水到渠成的行为,但是和前面的步骤能够形成很多联动,比如从牌桌“收牌”的时候可以“若无其事”的把所需要的牌利用换牌布置成想要的牌序,再利用切牌换到想要的位置; EV扑克软件使用GGPoker授权,致力打造亚洲最具公信力与趣味性最多元的扑克平台,bmm发牌认证,公平公正公开,信誉获得国内外用户肯定支持,丰富的赛制体验以及带给玩家极致乐趣是我们的终极目标! 老虎机游戏单机免费大满贯版 比赛中我选择的音乐种类繁多,用不同的音乐来配合我当时的玩牌风格。如果是一场持久的比赛,我有很多筹码,并且桌上有一两位疯狂的选手,那么我就采取等待态度,听一些悠闲的音乐。如果桌上局势紧张,筹码开始缩减,并且到了加大马力的时候,那么我会听一些摇滚或现代电子乐令自己绷紧神经。

  53. I’ll right away take hold of your rss feed as I can’t find your email subscription hyperlink or e-newsletter service. Do you have any? Please allow me recognise so that I could subscribe. Thanks.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.