Laxmibai Chandaragi B. And Anr. vs. The State Of Karnataka And Ors. [2021 SCC OnLine SC 85]

Legal Aid Society, Campus Law Centre, University of Delhi

Laxmibai Chandaragi B. And Anr. vs. The State Of Karnataka And Ors. [2021 SCC OnLine SC 85]

June 27, 2022 Legal Juice: Judgment Summaries 4465

Coram: Sanjay Kishan Kaul, J. and Hrishikesh Roy, J.

Facts: In the instant case,

one Mr. Basappa Chandaragi lodged a complaint with the Murgod Police Station, Belagavi District, Karnataka stating that his daughter, Ms. Laxmibai Chandaragi, Petitioner No. 1 herein was missing since 14.10.2020. In pursuance to the complaint, an FIR of a missing person was registered. From the call details, it became apparent that Petitioner No. 1 was in contact with Mr. Santosh Singh Yadav, Petitioner No. 2. In the course of investigation, it was found that Petitioner No. 1, apparently without informing her parents, had travelled to Delhi, and thereafter, married Petitioner No. 2. Subsequently,Petitioner No. 1 sent her marriage certificate to her parents through Whatsapp on 15.10.2020.

The Investigating Officer (“IO”) proceeded to Ghaziabad, Uttar Pradesh to know the whereabouts of Petitioner No.1 and visited the residence of Petitioner No. 2 in Ghaziabad. Petitioner No. 1 spoke to the IO and informed that she had already married Petitioner No. 2 and was residing with him. But, the IO instead insisted that Petitioner No. 1 appear before the Murgod Police Station to record a statement so that the case of missing person can be closed. Petitioner No. 1 sent a letter to the IO stating that there was threat from her parents, and thus, she was unable to visit the police station. The case of missing person was still not closed by the IO.

It is in the aforesaid circumstances, that the present petition wasfiled by the Petitioners before the Hon’ble Supreme Court under Article 32 of the Constitution of India.

Contentions of the Petitioner:

The present petition has been filed under Article 32 since there is an issue of duality of jurisdiction arising from her residing with Petitioner No.2 in Uttar Pradesh and Petitioner No.1 originally being from Karnataka.
Since the uncle of Petitioner No.1 was threatening them,
the latter was apprehensive of visiting the police station.
The IO frightened the Petitioners by stating that the family members may file an FIR that Petitioner No. 1 has stolen things from the home which could lead to the arrest of Petitioner No. 2 leading to problems for his career.
Decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court:
The Hon’ble Court quashed the proceedings emanating from the said FIR by noting that as the Petitioners have filed the present petition, no further statement is required to be recorded. It further held that proceedings are quashed with the hope that the parents of Petitioner No. 1 will have a better sense to accept the marriage.

Observations of the Hon’ble Supreme Court:

Deprecating the conduct of the IO, the Hon’ble Court held that the IO could have visited the residence of Petitioner No.2 and easily recorded the statement of Petitioner No.1 rather than insisting and calling the Petitioners to the local police station in Karnataka. It was further noted that the IO undoubtedly compelled Petitioner No.1 to visit the police station on the threat of possibility of a false case being registered by her parents against Petitioner No. 2. Therefore, the Hon’ble Court directed that the officer be sent for counselling as to how to manage such cases. It further highlighted the need to devise a training programme for police personnel to deal with such socially sensitive cases as well as to counsel the current IOs.

The Hon’ble Supreme Court further noted that fact that both the parties were well educated, major and married each other consensually. It observed that educated younger boys and girls are choosing their life partners which, in turn is a departure from the earlier norms of society where caste and community play a major role. Possibly, this is the way forward where caste and community tensions will reduce but in the meantime these youngsters face threats from the elders, and the Courts have been coming to the aid of these youngsters.

Taking strength from Shakti Vahini v. Union of India [(2018) 7 SCC 192], the Hon’ble Supreme Court reiterated that the consent of the family or the community or the clan is not necessary once the two adult individuals agree to enter into a wedlock, and that their consent has to be piously given primacy. It further relied on the case of Asha Ranjan v. State of Bihar [(2017) 4 SCC 397], wherein it was held that the choice of an individual is an inextricable part of dignity, for dignity cannot be thought of where there is erosion of choice. Such a right or choice is not expected to succumb to the concept of “class honour” or “group thinking.” Error! Hyperlink reference not valid. Furthermore i

n Shafin Jahan v. Asokan K M (2018), the Hon’ble Supreme Court noticed that the intimacies of marriage lie within a core zone of privacy, which is inviolable. The right to marry a person of choice was held to be an integral part of Article 21 of the Constitution of India. The case of K.S. Puttaswamy v. Union of India (2018) was also referred to where the autonomy of an individual inter alia in relation to family and marriage were held to be integral to the dignity of an individual.

On an optimistic note
, the Hon’ble Court quoted Dr. B.R. Ambedkar who wrote:

the real remedy is inter-marriage. Fusion of blood can alone create the feeling of being kith and kin, and unless this feeling of kinship, of being kindred, becomes paramount, the separatist feeling—the feeling of being aliens—created by Caste will not vanish

4,465 Responses

  1. Wonderful website. Lots of helpful info here.

    I’m sending it to some friends ans additionally sharing in delicious.
    And certainly, thank you in your effort!

  2. Yes! Finally something about buy instagram followers.

  3. I am very happy to read this. This is the type of manual that needs to be given and not the accidental misinformation that is at the other blogs. Appreciate your sharing this best doc.

  4. Emiko Milton says:

    Hi would you mind sharing which blog platform you’re working with? I’m going to start my own blog in the near future but I’m having a hard time making a decision between BlogEngine/Wordpress/B2evolution and Drupal. The reason I ask is because your layout seems different then most blogs and I’m looking for something completely unique. P.S Sorry for getting off-topic but I had to ask!

  5. Abelige says:

    Not to mention feeding the stereo-type that if a woman has a sex toy she doesn t need a man partner, and vice versa buy cialis viagra The night of interior includes not on the colon a feature comprises to coincide

  6. heitinK says:

    Answer Never cialis and priligy Since levocetirizine blocks histamine from activating the H1 receptors, the symptoms that are typically caused by histamine are lessened

  7. Hello there, You have performed an excellent job. I will definitely digg it and in my view recommend to my friends. I am sure they will be benefited from this web site.

  8. advicky says:

    Ask your health care provider any questions you may have about how to use Cialis cialis on line 5 8 TABLETS Save 28

  9. Neendub says:

    It could be nothing though, I just wanted to see if it happened to any twin mamas. buy clomiphene online

  10. very nice post, i actually love this web site, carry on it

  11. Thanks for the sensible critique. Me & my neighbor were just preparing to do some research on this. We got a grab a book from our local library but I think I learned more from this post. I’m very glad to see such excellent info being shared freely out there.

  12. gauptex says:

    Also you need to drink plenty of water. nolvadex dosage

  13. sheelty says:

    ofloxacin increases effects of repaglinide by pharmacodynamic synergism. oracea

  14. free slots 777 vagas world slots free poker slots lucky slots on facebook

  15. buy cheap paper paper writers online paper writing services for college students paper writing service college

  16. help with your paper buy college papers custom handwriting paper academic paper writing services

  17. dltk custom writing paper write my business paper buying papers papers writing service

  18. i will pay you to write my paper will you write
    my paper for me where can i find someone to write
    my college paper do my college paper

  19. some to write my paper cheap paper writing services pay
    someone to write a paper website that will write a paper for you

  20. college paper ghost writer paper help writing need help write my paper website that writes papers for you

  21. someone to write my paper for me help in writing paper pay someone
    to write paper help writing a paper for college

  22. help with filing divorce papers custom papers custom handwriting paper cheap paper writing services

  23. help with writing paper help with your paper paper writer service pay someone to write a paper

  24. paper writing service professional paper writer help with college paper writing write my nursing paper

  25. buy a paper for college order paper online paper writers who can write my paper for me

    • odossenow says:

      Treating dairy cows naturally Thoughts and strategies discount cialis It has been recorded in history that the winner of the 480BC Olympic Games diet consisted of nothing but meat for 10 months straight in preparation for the Olympic Games 2, and it is well understood that meats especially red meats contain large quantities of the various B vitamins, and creatine all proven to enhance athletic performance to some degree

  26. pay to write papers professional paper writing services do my college paper for me

  27. odostesah says:

    TAM has been effectively used in the treatment of breast cancer for more than 3 decades, yet the molecular mechanisms underlying TAM induced regression of human breast tumors remain unclear cialis prices Spratt Donald E, Walden H, Shaw GS

  28. pay to do paper write my paper for money custom paper writing paper writing services best

  29. pay to do paper academic paper writers custom written college papers buy a paper for college

  30. help me write my paper paper writing service reviews what should i write
    my paper on do my paper for money

  31. pay for someone to write your paper pay someone to do my
    paper write my paper in 3 hours custom paper service

  32. Davidrow says:

    dark web drug marketplace tor market

  33. Grantsog says:

    dark web drug marketplace darknet links

    • odossenow says:

      IUI was performed in only one patient and this patient failed to conceive 1, so our case report describes the first patient to successfully conceive using IUI following fertility sparing surgery and chemotherapy for ovarian IT where can i buy azithromycin Well described are the expression of pili, which assist in adhesion and colonisation; the ability to bind to human albumin by way of a peptostreptococcal albumin binding protein leading to accelerated growth rates; and expression of superantigens targeting B cells the most common being Protein L 7, 11, 12

  34. Brandentut says:

    blackweb official website incognito darknet market – darknet market sites and how to access

  35. enp says:

    Excellent goods from you, man. I have understand yoour stuff previous too andd yoou aree
    just tooo fantastic. I resally ljke what you’ve acquured here, certaiinly like what
    youu aree srating aand tthe way iin which yoou saay it. You make it enjoyablle andd yyou sfill takke care of
    to keep iit sensible. I can nnot wait to rea far mkre frokm you.
    Thiis iss actuallly a great website.

  36. HellyCah says:

    blackweb official website darknet sites

  37. Edgarjom says:

    deep web drug url darkfox market – legit darknet markets 2022

    • odossenow says:

      On bivariate analysis, factors significantly associated with actuarial rate of first CVA included hypertension P cialis on line According to experts, for professionals who take steroids frequently and in high doses, it is difficult to protect themselves from side effects related to estrogen conversion with Clomid

    • tretilt says:

      cialis from usa pharmacy Stourac P, Adamus M, Seidlova D, Pavlik T, Janku P, Krikava I, Mrozek Z, Prochazka M, Klucka J, Stoudek R, Bartikova I, Kosinova M, Harazim H, Robotkova H, Hejduk K, Hodicka Z, Kirchnerova M, Francakova J, Obare Pyszkova L, Hlozkova J, Sevcik P

  38. ADiodip says:

    dark web search engine blackweb

    • tretilt says:

      Prior to the advent of macrolide antibiotics in the treatment of NTM diseases, regimens of rifampicin, ethambutol and amikacin were tried, after three way synergy was observed in vitro 73 cialis with dapoxetine In keeping with the prediction of the TTM, adherence was sustained when women perceived that the benefits of therapy outweighed the risks, whereas discontinuance was likely when perceived risks outweighed, or were similar to, benefits

  39. HectorSip says:

    darknet market list darknet illicit drugs – best dark web markets 2022

  40. Richardunema says:

    darknet markets top darknet markets – darknet market noobs step by step

  41. Richardunema says:

    deep web drug markets darknet market reddit – underground hackers black market

  42. Brandentut says:

    deep web drug url dark web search tool – best mdma vendor darknet market reddit

  43. Zacharywen says:

    blackweb official website tor darknet

  44. SteveTonry says:

    blackweb official website dark markets belgium – black market websites 2022